Is BookTok killing the publishing industry? 

By Daisy Hill

As with other industries, the publishing industry is becoming increasingly influenced by TikTok. According to the BBC, ‘#BookTok’ has been viewed over 200 billion times and has been used on a total of 36.8 million videos. The sheer number of people engaging with this online community is transforming the publishing industry at an accelerated pace.

This is evident both online and on the high street. Many bookshops, such as Waterstones, now have dedicated tables in store for trending titles on BookTok. This in turn demonstrates the decisions made by publishing houses to pursue those genres and authors whom they believe will be popular on BookTok and thus will sell well. For instance, on Harper Collins’ ‘Browse and shop’ webpage can be found sub-sections titled ‘BookTok favourites’ and ‘romantasy’, a popular genre on TikTok. Additionally, well-known BookTok content creators are now being approached by publishers to advertise new titles; Random House has said that they now work with around one hundred content creators, demonstrating the growing influence TikTok has in determining new best-sellers. The UK bestsellers list of 2023 features titles which were trending on TikTok for months in 2023, notably It Ends with Us by Colleen Hoover at number six, and Lessons in Chemistry by Bonnie Garmus at number three. 

Undeniably, TikTok has had a profound impact upon the publishing industry, but it has also strongly influenced the reading habits of a generation of readers aged between 16–34. BookTok has encouraged more young people to read for enjoyment by creating a mostly positive environment in which anyone can post reviews of, and engage with, literature. This is important as literary communities can often be exclusionary to less experienced readers. 

BookTok has encouraged more young people to read for enjoyment by creating a mostly positive environment in which anyone can post reviews of, and engage with, literature

However, BookTok has received much backlash both on and off the app for a multitude of reasons. There have been concerns regarding explicit adult books marketed towards young adults and teenagers due to misleading book covers and marketing. Additionally, there has been controversy over ‘brainrot’ books, with some TikTok users calling for a distinction between ‘BookTok’ and ‘LiteratureTok’, insinuating that the standard of writing in popular BookTok books is poor, promoting an anti-intellectualism discussion on the topic earlier this year. 

As BookTok mainly consists of young female readers, it is also useful to consider sexism as a factor in the debates that have arisen surrounding anti-intellectualism on TikTok. The dismissal and mockery of popular books among young women follows along the line of critique that ‘basic’ teenage girls face in every medium: from television, music and now literature. 

As BookTok mainly consists of young female readers, it is also useful to consider sexism as a factor in the debates that have arisen surrounding anti-intellectualism on TikTok

Finally, BookTok has been criticized for its ‘fast fashion’ approach to reading, often encouraging users to buy books through posting videos such as ‘book hauls’ or ‘bookshelf tours’. Guardian columnist Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett wrote an article in 2023 critiquing the ‘cult of book ownership’ and those who believe owning books is a ‘stand in for a personality.’ Though BookTok is not mentioned specifically in her article, similar critiques of BookTok have emerged on the app due to the focus on consumerism. 

BookTok is changing the way in which publishers select stories for publishing, demonstrated by the rise in availability of the romantasy genre, for example. Whilst this is good news for the people who enjoy this genre, will it limit opportunities for those authors whose books do not align with the demands of BookTok? Is the industry becoming saturated with badly written books to keep up with demand for specific tropes? Or is this an elitist view? Or sexist? Whatever the case, BookTok will continue to have lasting influence on the publishing industry for as long as its users keep buying, and promoting, new books. 

Image credit: Janet Benoy via Flickr