Iranian regime funded seminar goes ahead despite criticism

Durham University has been criticised for hosting an Iranian-funded seminar on 28th January as authorities in Tehran hanged two young men who were arrested during protests that followed Iran’s dispute presidential election last year.
Mohammed Reza Ali-Zamani and Arash Rahmanipour had been convicted in unfair trials of “enmity against God” and their execution is believed to be the first in a series of young citizens’ related to the post-election violence that erupted across Iran in June and has continued since.
Meanwhile, far away in North-East England a public event, organised by the University’s Centre for Iranian Studies, was examining the relationship between culture and politics in post-Islamic Revolution Iran. The event was part of an ongoing programme which was arranged last year.
Anger over the violent oppression of opposition protests by the Islamic regime generated a row within the University when two of the four speakers chose not to attend and express their views because of the association with ICRO.
Dr Homa Katouzian, an Oxford-based academic who had been billed as the keynote speaker withdrew because of the controversy over the ties to the regime. Dr Khian, a colleague from the Univeristy of Paris, swiftly followed suit and soon a number of news websites  launched a campaign to ask the remaining scholars to condemn the extreme violation of human  rights  and stop co-operating with the Islamic Republic.
This resulted in the arrangement of replacement speakers. The event was briefly addressed by Ali Mohammad Helmi, the cultural attache at the Iranian embassy in London, who has been described as a hardline supporter of Iran’s supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.
Dr Colin Turner, co-director of Durham’s Centre for Iranian Studies, admitted the seminar was “monopolised” by the pro-regime replacement speakers. Yet he rejects the “wild and damaging allegation” of support for President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad that had been made against departmental staff by green activists, “These same people who denigrate us have absolutely no problem in accepting scholarships from the British government – which has turned the slaughter of innocent teenagers in Iraq and Afghanistan into an art form.
“Before they accuse us of receiving what they term ‘blood money’ from our Iranian funders, maybe they should look a little more closely at the source of their own funding”.
Controversially Dr Reza Molavi, the centre’s director, confirmed the seminar had received £5,000 of funding from the Iran Cultural Centre (ICRO), a cultural organisation dedicated to the preservation and promotion of Iran’s rich heritage equivalent to the British Council. However, in a statement from the University it is argued that the money was to be used specifically to fund events with a focus on Iranian culture, and ICRO did not dictate the themes or the titles of the papers presented in the series.
Green supporter Roya Farazman argued conversely, “It is crystal clear that the Iranian government supported this event not for the sake of academic discussion. Rather they are desperate for attention from reputable US and British universities”.
In attendance were Durham’s mayor and Vice-Chancellor Chris Higgins who defended the hosting, “While not condoning any extremist views Durham University embraces freedom of expression and welcomes open and challenging debate on controversial issues.  The seminar was compliant with our code of practice on freedom of expression and I myself attended part of the discussion and contributed to it.
Drawing comparisions with the recent cancellation of the Union Society’s debate on multicultaralism Higgins stated, “This event aimed to provide a forum where all sides of the debate were represented, but we could not oblige anyone to attend. The withdrawal of individual speakers from the conference was a matter for their own conscience but we were all disappointed as we lost the opportunity to hear their opinions, and they lost the opportunity to have them heard.
“The University has clear guidelines on the receipt and use of funding, which comes from a variety of sources, including our own government. On no occasion do we allow our academic freedom of expression to be compromised unless the safety and security of our staff and students is at risk.”
However Iranian doctoral student Afshin Shahi responded, “Our vice-chancellor personally attended the event and astonishingly emphasised the need for  “dialogue” and “debate” with the Islamic Republic. That was a very sad day for both human rights and Durham University.  How could he justify his point when the ruling regime in Tehran is known as one of the worst enemies of freedom of expression in the world? Almost every major human rights organisation has condemned the brutal tactics of the state to undermine freedom of expression”.
“The objective of the Iranian regime to invest in Durham University is not to promote “mutual understanding” between Iran and a bunch of academics in the North East of England! This “engagement” is quite symbolic and is initiated for internal political consumption. By gaining a platform in a prestigious British university, they prove  that, despite their grave violation of human rights, they are still respected and accepted by the “western academics” , so they must be “right”! It is not surprising that their conferences at Durham University are always widely reported by the official press in Iran”.
Iranian students across the UK are also enraged by the fact that Shahi’s fellow Durham postgraduate student Ehsan Abdo-Tabrizi is missing after apparently being detained in Tehran over Christmas. He has not been heard from since being ordered to meet government officials.
However, in a statement from the University regarding this, they say, “We are extremely concerned with the as-yet unsubstantiated report regarding the welfare of one of our postgraduate students. The student was at the stage in his studies where he had completed a programme of research and was writing his thesis, and had chosen to do this away from Durham as permitted by University procedures. We take the safety and security of our students very seriously and are making urgent further enquiries”.
Dr Turner, who supervised Tabrizi, insisted he was “completely aware that conferences … are seen as propaganda opportunities by the Iranian regime”. In a slight change of tune Turner wrote that they would not accept funding from the same sponsors again.“Iranian money comes with strings attached, as we have found to our chagrin”.
Similarly Dr Katouzian’s star pupil, doctoral candidate Mohammadreza Jalaeipour, was also arrested on a visit to Iran during the unrest after last June’s disputed presidential election. He is now on bail but unable to leave the country.
Shahi reflected on this. “Over the last few months, hundreds of people have been arrested – Iranian prisons are now turning into universities, there are so many intellectuals in jail. There are a number of students in custody facing intolerable conditions for voicing their opinion, “incompatible” lecturers are forced to resign and every platform for expression has been harshly dismantled. Any newspaper that has any vague critical line is closed down and journalists are imprisoned. The Ministry of Justice in Iran has just announced that soon they will hang nine more people for protesting against the government. It seems this shocking news and the atrocities taking place in the Iranian torture chambers such as raping male and female protesters, have been heard by most people in the world except by some people in charge at Durham University”.
However, Dr Reza Molavi told The Guardian,“We don’t think that by isolating them we will do any favours to Iran or Iranians. These students who have raised Cain about this are young and temperamental and may have made decisions that are not in tune with what realities dictate”.