Iran funds Durham democracy seminar
AN ACADEMIC SEMINAR due to take place in Durham tomorrow is sponsored by the Islamic Republic of Iran, Palatinate has learned.
The seminar, entitled ‘Iranian theocracy and democracy: convergence or contradiction?’, is to be jointly presented by Durham University’s Centre for Iranian Studies and the Cultural Centre of the Islamic Republic of Iran UK. The seminar begins at 11.00 am on Wednesday 10 December at the Al-Qasami building on Elvet Hill Road, adjacent to St. Mary’s College.
The Islamic Republic News Agency, the news service of the Iranian government, issued a press release on December 5 which describes the aim of the seminar as the discussion of “different aspects of religious democracy under the Islamic republic” and claims that “the seminar will be held in line with a memorandum of understanding sealed between the Cultural Consulate of the Iranian Embassy and the University of Durham.”
The press release also reports a statement from Ali Mohammad Helmi, the Cultural Consul of the Iranian Embassy in London who said: “I hope the governance pattern of the Islamic republic presented by Imam Khomeini could be introduced in details to the British academics and students, […] No other country in the Islamic world except for the Islamic Republic of Iran attaches such a great significance to the role of the public in administering the state of affairs. That’s why the ruling system in Iran has turned it into a unique system in the Middle East and among the Muslim world.”
Durham University issued a statement on 5 December. Dr Reza Molavi, executive Director of the Centre for Iranian Studies, explained: “The Memorandum of Understanding is aimed at exchanging scholars and students in order to better understand the issues surrounding Iran which is one of the most strategically and politically important countries in the Middle East region today.
“Any money the University has been provided with is to cover expenses associated with the event. Durham University embraces freedom of expression and welcomes open and challenging debate on controversial issues so long as that freedom of expression is within the law. Durham has been a diverse university for many years, and we follow national guidelines on promoting good campus relations and on ensuring staff and students can live and work in a respectful and tolerant environment.”
Critics of the Iranian regime will not be satisfied, however. The commentator David Toube raised questions over the news on the political website, Harry’s Place. He told Palatinate: “There has never been a more urgent need to study the Iranian political system. However, it worries me that the Islamic Republic of Iran claims to be sponsoring – under a ‘Memorandum of Understanding’ – a conference on its political system. Will refugees and those who have suffered from, and escaped Iran’s ‘religious democracy’ be invited to participate? Has the University of Durham thought about how Iranian dissidents must feel, knowing that a Government that has persecuted them, is sponsoring such an event?
“Iran’s ‘religious democracy’ is a sham. Thousands of mildly reformist candidates are routinely disqualified by the Guardian Council prior to each Iranian election. Trade unionists, liberals and minorities are routinely arrested, tortured and executed in order to keep this ‘religious democracy’ in place. Meanwhile, the Islamic Republic holds international conferences, at which European neo-Nazis are invited to promote Holocaust denial.”
Iran’s sponsorship of a seminar in Durham is reminiscent of the controversy that ensued when SOAS accepted a donation from the Iranian government in 1999, raising concerns about academic integrity. Since then, diplomatic relations between Iran and the West have suffered due to Iran’s determination to pursue nuclear capability in the face of international pressure. In particular, Britain’s relationship with Iran took a body blow last year when 15 British naval personnel were captured by the Iranian military in Iraqi waters.
Concerns may also be roused by the way that the seminar has been presented on university listings. The Iranian Cultural Consul’s characterisation of the event as a discussion of Iranian democracy will come as a surprise to any student who noticed the details of the event on the university website’s ‘What’s On?’ page, or on the events page of the School of Government and International Affairs, which provides only the title of the first lecture of several which are part of the seminar: ‘Professor Charles Melville, Director of Oriental Studies in Pembroke College, Cambridge will deliver this Public Lecture: “The right to rule and power to command in Ferdowsi’s Shahnameh”’. Indeed, the event is listed as part of the ‘Ferdowsi lecture series’ – Ferdowsi being a Persian poet of around 1000AD.
On the University listings, Iran’s sponsorship is not clear. The official listings refer variously to “the Cultural Centre of Iran (UK)” and “The Cultural Centre of IR Iran UK” – in both cases the term ‘Islamic Republic’ has is either absent or only represented by initials, which could be mistaken for ‘International Relations’.
Vice-Chancellor, Prof. Chris Higgins acknowledged that the listing is “significantly misleading” and said that the website will be corrected.
David Toube continued: “Iran has a history of organising ‘cultural events’ at British Universities, in order to provide it with the appearance of respectability. I very much hope that Durham hasn’t been suckered into one of these scams.”
Prof. Higgins, however, reiterated the sentiment of Dr Molavi’s statement: “This is a normal academic conference and the University is proud to embrace freedom of speech and ideas from around the world, and to hold such conferences on controversial but important subjects.”
Correction: When Prof. Higgins told us that ‘the website is significantly misleading’, it was assumed that his reference was to Durham’s own website. In fact, he meant the website of the Islamic Republic News Agency. We apologise for this honest mistake.
