Iowa in Perspective: A Losers’ Battleground
By Olivia Ryan
Yes, America, we get it – the 2016 presidential elections are “around the corner”. And now that the Iowa caucuses have actually happened maybe the field will narrow down at least a little bit, and the crazy candidates like Donald Trump will fade into the background.
Wait, what? He came in second place in the Iowa caucus? Where even is Iowa?
Ah, Iowa. The Hawkeye State. Home of the…well, nothing much other than the Iowa caucuses. And a lot of corn. Demographically, Iowa does not represent the rest of the 300-million-strong US population: it’s heavily white, conservative and Christian. But while some argue that the Iowa caucus is not an indicator for the winner of the national election, historically the nominee has been in the top three, with the exception of Republican John McCain in 2008 and Bill Clinton in 1992.
So do the Iowa caucuses matter? For a handful of people, yes – that is, the candidates themselves. The only significance of Iowa is that it’s the first time voters actually get to vote (or, say who they’ll actually vote for come November). A strong Iowa win is a notch up the confidence ladder. A big loss is often the final push to end a campaign (Martin O’Malley, Rand Paul, Mike Huckabee). Additionally, the media’s obsession with Iowa means that winners get more coverage, and losers will be further ignored. So yes, the Iowa caucus matters, but mostly only because the media says it does.
Additionally, the Iowa caucuses are not a simple fill-in-the-bubble vote. The aim of the caucuses is to elect local delegates for county conventions, who then select the delegates for the State Convention, who then select the delegates for the presidential nominating conventions, all part of the electoral college process. But in order to vote, the residents actually have to go. For the GOP, an ordinary secret ballot vote is held to tally totals statewide. For the Democrats, it’s a long event where supporters have to go and physically stand with their preferred candidate. Failing to secure enough supporters in a precinct means elimination from the contest.
Because the Iowa style is so personal, candidates need to invest a lot of time and money into putting on events, meeting voters, running ads. Essentially, winning the Iowa caucus is a nod to whoever has managed to drum up enough publicity through appearances or, in 2016’s case, through ridiculous comments. If a candidate has the kind of money to afford this kind of coverage now, it’s a sign that their campaign will probably have the stamina to hold out to the end.
The significance this year is that Donald Trump didn’t win. While he enjoys a lot of support in the polls, he couldn’t accumulate the support at the voting booth. Instead, Iowa chose Ted Cruz. Ben Carson seems to have lost his previous heat with a fourth-place finish, nearly fourteen percentage points behind the very solid Marco Rubio. Despite Jeb Bush nabbing early endorsements, he didn’t do so well in Iowa. Governor Chris Christie made little to no effort, since he recognized that it would be futile to try win the support of a majority-Evangelical Christian state. Most of the Republican candidates will hold out for next week’s New Hampshire primaries, but the field should whittle down quickly afterwards. Historically, the winner of the nomination has won either Iowa or New Hampshire (or both). On the Democrat side, Martin O’Malley ended his campaign after receiving only 0.6% of the votes; the rest were split almost equally between Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders (Clinton was announced as the winner).
The two winners of the Republican caucuses were Ted Cruz and Donald Trump, both polarizing figures. Marco Rubio is a very strong candidate and one to watch in New Hampshire.
In combination with the New Hampshire primaries which will be held on Tuesday 9 February, the Iowa caucus has the potential to determine a lot, especially for the losers. But for us on the outside of the two states, the campaigns and the country, it doesn’t really matter much.
Photograph: Gage Skidmore via Flickr
