Initiations are wrong but could do some good

By Emma Chapman

For many Durham students, getting involved with sports and societies is a key part of university life. Fast forward past freshers’ week and rumours of infamous sports initiations begin to circulate. A mass game of Chinese Whispers – “Did you hear what the rugby boys are made to do?” and “My friend in 3rd year says her’s was awful…” – stirs fear in new students.

Student media are no strangers to initiation horror stories. Last year, The Tab published an article detailing the worst of the lot, from apple bobbing for dead rats at Manchester‘s rugby team to drinks mixed with dog food and raw eggs at York’s hockey squad.

The backlash against such stories and fears for student welfare means universities, including Durham, have banned initiations to prevent excessive drinking and bullying. Yet the practice is strongly rooted and, if anything, the crackdown adds a child-like thrill to initiations. There’s now the added excitement of knowing that what you’re doing is secretive and under the radar.

So despite Durham University banning initiations in 2007, the tradition lives on through a new name: “Welcome Drinks”. The concept remains unchanged – to boost the ego of returning students and frighten freshers.

The ban has had some effect over the years, with fewer and fewer groups holding hardcore initiations. However, it is unlikely that we will see a complete end to the practice. No cohort wants to be the group to kill initiations entirely. If you suffered initiations as a fresher, you want to have your turn with the power. Shouldn’t you have a go at the “fun” too?

“So for initiations to be a positive and exciting experience for everyone, we need to remove the fear.”

However, the so-called ‘Welcome Drinks’ aren’t all bad. If the layers of bravado and “fresher-bashing” are stripped back, at its heart an initiation serves a simple purpose: to bring new members into the club. If you don’t mind White Ace being duct-taped to your hands and can successfully follow demands to strawpedo a bottle of wine, an initiation can bring club members closer together and improve team cohesion.

So for initiations to be a positive and exciting experience for everyone, we need to remove the fear. Freshers should feel comfortable in the knowledge that they will not be forced to drink alcohol, nor will they be forever condemned by the club for refusing to do a disgusting task. Some freshers, simply joining the club to play sport on a Saturday morning, may not want to take part at all. That too should be welcomed.

By changing the nature of initiations to focus on cultivating club spirit instead of humiliation and disgrace, they can be used as a force for good. It is unfair to deprive freshers of the excitement of being welcomed into their new club, as it is equally unfair to continue normalising cruel practices. Things need to change. And if they do, we may see better sports performances, stronger team bonding and happier members. After all, a team built on mutual respect will always beat a team built on fear.

Image by Czarina Alegre via Flickr