Independent Group: A fresh face in politics

By Anna Gray

Recently the UK political system was shaken by the defection of seven Labour and three Tory MPs to form The Independent Group. Whilst not yet registering as a political party these MPs are strongly critical of recent moves towards the extreme left and right in each of the mainstream parties, and favour a more centrist approach. On their website, the group calls for a ‘different culture’ in order to fix the broken politics of the current two major political parties, which they see as racist and pulling Britain towards chaos.[

It remains to be seen in these early days whether the group will have a meaningful effect on British politics, however when looking at the impact of groups with even fewer MPs, such as UKIP, there is certainly potential for them to cause seismic shifts in our political system.

The group calls for a ‘different culture’ in order to fix the broken politics of the current two major political parties

 


Nevertheless, a persistent question has been whether these MP’s must stand for re-election. Jeremy Corbyn, in response to the resignations, called on the seven Labour MPs to stand for re-election, saying it was the ‘decent and democratic’ thing to do.

However, it isn’t legally essential since, whilst they have left their political party, they haven’t defected to another party; and voters elect the individual they want as their MP, rather than a specific party. Whilst voters can themselves trigger a by-election by calling for a petition to recall their MP, this is only possible in specific circumstances, such as a criminal conviction.

A persistent question has been whether these MP’s must stand for re-election

Standing for re-election would also pose the significant risk of dividing the left-leaning vote, and giving the Tories a better chance of taking the seat.

The group themselves argue they should not stand for re-election as the public are sick of the recent spate of votes. Yet this sits rather uneasily with their support of a Second Referendum on the final Brexit deal and has prompted accusations of hypocrisy from their critics.

The group markets themselves as challenging the current political culture; however, their reluctance to participate in a by-election arguably fits closer the stereotype of a political class alienated from the people, and who fail to offer a coherent message.

Their reluctance to participate in a by-election arguably fits the stereotype of a political class alienated from the people

Despite this flaw in their message, the Independent Group has started a conversation in British politics about the viability of the two major political parties and the impact of Brexit which has been brewing for a long time.

Whether they eventually stand for election or not, the group has already started to influence the major parties, with Jeremy Corbyn’s recent indication that he could back a second referendum arguably a response to the group’s Brexit stance. It will be interesting to see when and if these MPs stand for re-election; however, as Brexit fast approaches, the public may not appreciate further political disruption.

Photo: Kasim Rashid via Flicr