In the race for the French presidency, multiculturalism hangs in the balance
France has been shaken to its very core this week by the narcissistic actions of an Islamic fundamentalist, intent on killing in the name of a perverted vision of his own faith. Mohammed Merah’s victims included three Muslim French soldiers who had fought for France in Afghanistan, three Jewish children, and a Rabbi.
France is in the midst of a particularly heated Presidential election which was put on hold this week as the security services tracked down Merah, eventually killing him in a bloody shoot out in Toulouse on Thursday morning.
The corollary political effects of this terrorist attack are hugely important. First off, the issues surrounding immigration and the integration of different ethnicities into French secular society have bubbled to the surface once again. Merah was a French national and had lived in a deprived suburb of Toulouse for virtually his entire life, barring a brief spell in the Middle East, where he gained training from Al-Qaeda. His Islamic identity has predictably given France’s political extreme right, (led by Marine Le Pen but mimicked by Nicolas Sarkozy) a bolstered bully pulpit ahead of the election.
Le Pen has no feasible chance of winning the election, but her voters will be crucial in the second round, likely to be between Sarkozy and Hollande. In the weeks leading up to the attacks, Sarkozy predictably tacked to the right on the divisive issue of immigration, in a desperate scramble to attract the Front National voters that could ensure his return to the Elysée Palace.
For Sarkozy, the attacks represent a golden opportunity. Had Merah escaped the police for any longer than a week, Sarkozy’s re-election bid would have surely been doomed. But with the crisis resolved on the ground, Sarkozy marches on with renewed credibility, and is looking to extract as much momentum from the shock waves rippling through French society as he possibly can.
The President has perceptively attempted to avert the inevitable maelstrom of abjectly anti-Islamic rhetoric by emphasizing Merah’s profile as a rogue and psychopathic loner who can in no way be linked to mainstream Islamic beliefs. Subsequently, he has tried to shift the issue onto his preferred electoral stomping-ground, that of law and order. It is here that he can land substantial body blows to Francois Hollande’s hitherto watertight campaign.
Sarkozy has already started to plug the line that his Socialist counterpart resembles the sort of wishy-washy lefty that can’t be trusted to keep the country safe against the horrors of Islamic terrorism. However unsubstantiated the argument may be, ‘soft’ socialists that are seen to neglect anti-terrorism laws are, as ever, an easy target for the right when national security is at stake.
Hollande will do well to shake off Sarkozy’s smears in the coming weeks. He cannot hope to match the President’s credibility on law and order; currently, it looks as if he will continue to beat the anti-Sarkozy drum, arguing that the President’s sudden renewed strength on anti-terrorism is another example of his reactive policies and his political schizophrenia.
Unfortunately, this tactic does not deal with Hollande’s fundamental problem. He needs to find a way of simultaneously embracing the unified national healing resulting from the attacks, but also unearth a method that shifts the campaign’s emphasis back towards France’s creaking economy. It is here where he will find his electoral safe-haven and the weeping thorn in Sarkozy’s side.
However, Merah has inadvertently unearthed a much wider issue in French politics. The French model of assimilative integration is fragile at the best of times. Yet France’s disjointed social cohesion trickles down from the heated rhetoric of its elite. Merah was a French national: born, bred and radicalized in France. The only thing he received from foreign shores in his quest for misguided martyrdom was training.
France has a strong Republican model based on a strict secularist separation of the church and the state, which works in theory. But in reality, issues of religion and ethnicity burst the leaking seams of French society every day. France must recognize the role played by aggressive anti-immigration public rhetoric in creating monsters like Mohammed Merah.
Before Merah’s identity became evident, both left and right colluded in an unflattering propaganda war. The right blamed Islamic fundamentalism and lambasted the left for its weakness and collusion, while the left blamed neo-fascism and castigated the right for its anti-immigrant rhetoric. In essence, both missed the point: France has a strong centralized state with a remarkably diverse, if disjointed society. The blind failure of the former to acknowledge the prevalence and value of the latter lies at the heart of France’s interethnic social malaise.
Image of station clock from Olivia Rudgard. Image of multicultural French train carriage by mallol on Flickr.
David’s writing is also available on his blog at anidlemoment.com. Respond to his view by commenting below or tweeting us @PalatiComment.Â

