In defense of the Exec – Cuth’s JCR stands up to criticism

As many of you will know, there has recently been a spate of bad press about St Cuthbert’s Society. I am a Cuth’s first year, and I’m writing this article to both show the flip side to a rather unbalanced debate, but also to discourage others from using Palatinate as a public way to discredit their college or society.

After all, as Will Day said last issue, “such a public stance cannot facilitate the necessary partnership that should be in place between the Senior Management and the JCR.”

In Will’s article, he claimed that the JCR Executive are becoming increasingly irrelevant. I cannot for a moment see how this is true. The Exec exists to serve the student body – as such, it will never lose importance unless it ceases to be mandated by the JCR.

This is notably not happening in Cuth’s, as evidenced by the fact that during a time of general student apathy, more Cuth’s JCR meetings have been quorate this year than for a number of years. Students stand for Executive posts not to receive greater importance or recognition for their input, but because they care a lot about their college and want to get more involved.

To address the “silly” questions that some Cuthsmen have criticised, while Cuth’s Exec members rarely restrict the nature of questions asked, they are not the only ones to ask such questions. Students from all areas of the Society – everyone from enthusiastic freshers to apathetic third years who come to watch a friend hust – are free to ask whatever they like.

Of course there are traditional questions, such as ‘good pants, bad pants’ that are usually maintained by, if not an Exec member, then a veteran meeting-goer. Equally, at a recent hust I did for Social Chair, one of my friends who had never been to a meeting before mandated us to dance.

It’s not a culture bred by our Exec, but a natural inclination for all students to try to bring fun into every situation. The Exec’s only crime, perhaps, is to allow questions of that nature – if they didn’t, we may have seen an article in Palatinate last week about restricted freedom of speech. You simply can’t please everyone in this scenario.

I also find it necessary to enlighten people about the formals situation. The decision to boycott formals was not a stubborn decree made blindly by the Exec because the Senior Management had cut down on our alcohol allowance, but voted for by the JCR membership because they wanted to be treated like adults, and not have motions slid through over the summer when the Exec were both new and not all present in Durham. And while Professor Towl agreed to compromise (the reason why the boycott has lifted), formals have become an SCR-run event.

As someone who husted for Social Chair, I found it upsetting that part of my potential job had been taken away from me, and that I might have had to organise Cuth’s Day on a much restricted budget – and now my sympathies lie with the current and elected Social Chairs. We were concerned enough about losing profits of wine from formals, but now we lose the formal profits altogether.

I consider many members of the Exec to be friends of mine, and so have seen how hard they all work at their jobs. I have attended some Executive meetings, which go on for several hours, and have far less casual banter than JCR meetings have.

They also work with commendable dedication within their job capacities: for example, the Welfare Officer, Jill Chapman, once gave up her Monday night to drive me to the eye hospital. This is the extent to which the Exec go to do their jobs not just well, but exemplarily.

Rachael and Will praised many of the facilities of Cuths, but they seem to have overlooked that it’s the very people they are condemning who actually run those services. Imagine if you’d had your hard work criticised and disregarded in a public newspaper, without even a prior indication that people were less than pleased.

The responsibility to make a complaint is up to the person with the comment, and I don’t mean in Palatinate. How is the Exec expected to read the minds of the entire apathetic section of the Cuth’s student body?

Moreover, Will concludes that the man to be entrusted with this responsibility is the Principal, but (nothing against him personally), how can anyone presume that one man, with many other commitments, can do the hardest job of thirteen student representatives?

Despite claims that Cuth’s is “less organised, less structured and one step behind everyone else”, our JCR is one of the best-governed collegiate bodies within the university; after trying to find the constitution or standing orders of other colleges on their JCR websites, it appears that almost half of the colleges have no accessible governing documents, and that only 5 colleges actually have standing orders.

Not only are the St. Cuthbert’s constitution and standing orders fully available on our website, but they are probably some of the best. In addition, our governing documents are constantly being reviewed and improved, by JCR and Exec members alike.

I believe the St. Cuthbert’s Society Exec is one of those rare things that isn’t as good as you make it – it’s better. They work hard to do the very best they can, and, even in a time of such student apathy, manage to represent us to the best of their capabilities.

Whilst we have heard from two people with the opposing view, the fact that it was aired in Palatinate may have meant that it received much bigger hype than it merited.

I urge anyone who has a serious complaint to make it through the proper channels, so the Exec can consider it in perspective.

Conversely, if you think the Exec are doing a bloody good job, take the time to tell them. I’m sure they’d love some good news for a change.

If you have an opinion on this or any other issue, Palatinate would love to hear from you. Visit our website to comment Alternatively, send any articles to comment@palatinate.org.uk, and we’ll try to find space to air your views.