Imperial curriculum – friend or foe?

Mahika Mehrotra

Colonial-centric curriculum has been a subject of controversy since the ‘Decolonisation of the Curriculum’ movement began two decades ago. 2015 saw a reawakening of the campaign with the ‘Rhodes Must Fall’ undertaking. Most recently, the death of George Floyd has prompted a series of Black Lives Matter protests and created a platform for a discussion about race and colonialism.

Imperialism is intertwined with British history; one would assume it to be a national duty to educate the children of Britain about their colonial past. However, having had the unique experience of studying the British Empire as a topic at both A level and university level, I have found that undercurrents of white supremacy persist in imperial education. A colonial education which ignores the atrocities inherent to British rule is a foe to the impressionable young person.

“Undercurrents of white supremacy persist in imperial education.”

At A level, a course entitled ‘The British Empire 1857-1967’ seemed intriguing to the juvenile historian. However, it quickly became clear that the ‘British Empire’ which would be taught would focus primarily on white perspectives. Each student was provided with a list of forty-six recommended books; from this list, no text was authored by a colonised individual. To holistically portray the intricate details of British rule in the Americas, Africa and Asia without a single American, African or Asian perspective seemed equally as strange as impossible.

For example, a supposedly objective core text is Niall Ferguson’s Empire: How Britain Made the Modern World. He renders the empire as a force for good, sparking the industrialisation of the colonies and ‘enlightening’ them with western educational and political facilities. Few seventeen-year-olds, whose chief goal is to attain the top grades, have a desire to explore the nuance behind the topic. Historical education can become dangerous when taught in a manner which subtly glorifies the oppression of minorities.

University education is a somewhat different ball game. Even the module name, ‘Tensions of Empire: British Imperialism 1763-1963’, is indicative of a more well-rounded course; this study would not be a rudimentary list of Britain’s so-called ‘altruistic’ actions towards its colonies. Instead, learning about the empire at university would be a series of multifarious debates on the British government’s mores and morals regarding empire-building.

“Learning about the empire at university would be a series of multifarious debates.”

For example, while the A-level curriculum stated that Britain consciously terminated the slave trade as part of an ethical crusade, seminars at university carefully evaluated how the government sought the slave trade’s end to secure other – more economically beneficial – forms of colonialism.

Although the same few names appear again in key texts – Ferguson, Porter, Darwin and Gallagher (classically British scholars) – university students are encouraged to challenge these historians by referencing polemical scholars such as Tharoor and Elkins and their emotionally drenched critiques on the harrowing consequences of the empire. The true accolade of learning the British Empire at a university-level is not in the course content itself but in breeding inquisitive individuals.

“No history should be a foe – only a friend to the young mind.”

The education system is fostering another generation who are oblivious to Britain’s sinister past; the only manner in which to solve the problem of imperial curriculum is to change it. Imperial histories should be embedded into the curriculum from Key Stage 1; it is the duty of the British government to reconcile the children of the nation with all aspects of its colonial history. It is time for the sun to set on the idea that ignorance is bliss. The country must interrogate, understand and question its dark colonial narrative. No history should be a foe – only a friend to the young mind, henceforth inculcating the future torchbearers of political justice with an EQ just as palpable as their IQ.

Photograph: Open Grid Scheduler/ Grid Engine via Flickr and Creative Commons