Immigration’s benefits should be taken with its disadvantages

Job 600 x 400

by Dan Pront

The 2011 Census recently revealed that Polish is the second most spoken language in the UK. Members of the Business Centre Club of Poland may declare “gratulacje” (congratulations), as they just awarded Tony Blair with a “special prize” for facilitation Polish migration to the UK. For others this has given people deep food for thought at the prospect of lifting the living and working restrictions in 2014 on Romanians and Bulgarians.

When the Poles, Czechs and others were given unrestricted access to live and work in the UK in 2004, experts predicted that just 13,000 people would migrate to Britain. The census proved that, from Poland alone, 579,000 people have settled in the UK in just seven years making them the second-largest foreign born group living in the UK. Should we embrace the prospect that, in less than twelve months, twenty-nine million people from Romania and Bulgaria will have the same opportunity to seek a new life here in these green and pleasant lands?

It is important that politicians are able to have sensible and rational conversations about keeping a sustainable open door immigration policy

It is important that politicians are able to have sensible and rational conversations about keeping a sustainable open door immigration policy. Immigration is an issue of great importance to the public, yet mainstream politicians feel unable to express concerns regarding mass immigration fearing that they will be deemed a “racist”. The wealthy, liberal metropolitan elite are only praiseworthy of the colossal waves of immigration that we have seen in the past decade. Whilst they are perfectly entitled to cheer about the contribution immigrants have made to the economy and society in general, one must not ignore the impact this has had on the British working class. When Blair kindly opened the doors to Poland in 2004, unemployment was relatively low and the economy was in a relatively stable position. It would be unjust to say that immigrants from Eastern Europe “stole” British jobs because they arrived in the UK at a time where jobs in the unskilled and semi-skilled labour market were available. However the complete removal of immigration restrictions on Polish migration has made a profound impact on the shape of our society.

Labour now admits this was clearly a “mistake”; it was a myopic decision taken without any consideration for the long-term impacts of economic migrants settling down here permanently. Research shows that most economic migrants are not a burden on the state and actually take up very little of the welfare benefits that become available to them after being here for three months.

However the most significant impact that such immigration has had on Britain is that the bargaining power of the working classes has been drastically undermined by the willingness of Eastern Europeans to work longer for less pay and often in worse conditions. The problem is often wrongly associated with the immigrants themselves yet one cannot blame self-seeking individuals who are willing to work hard and who will take any job they can get.

The perpetuating myths that the British workforce is lazy and incompetent and that Eastern Europeans are far superior workers has created an ironic form of prejudice among employers who benefitted greatly from the influx of this unskilled labour. As the demand for jobs in general has been augmented by the economic crisis, the British working classes now have to compete with the fact that more than half a million Poles and other Eastern Europeans are available to do the work and are willing to accept less. Employers have no motivation to offer their employers more than the minimum wage because quite frankly if British people turn their noses up at what they offer, they can quite easily find someone Eastern European who will gladly take the job.

Whilst many would argue this is the reality of free-market capitalism, this added competition in the labour market was pushed upon the working classes by the party that historically existed to fight their corner. One of the few views I share with Tony Blair is that I have complete admiration for the Polish people who have come to Britain to work hard, use the opportunities available and contribute to our diverse society. However we cannot ignore the impact that this has on the labour market at a time of economic uncertainty.

British people should celebrate the fact that we are such a tolerant society but, in order to maintain our open borders, we must be mindful of the impact immigration has on people with lower incomes. Getting wrapped in the abstract ideals of multiculturalism, at the same time as ignoring crude economic facts and public concern, could have detrimental effects on all the mainstream parties.