If you care for the environment, don’t demolish the DSU

By Keturah Civelek

In 2020, few can deny that the climate crisis is here. The UK government has pledged to achieve net zero carbon emissions by 2050, and Boris Johnson has promised to make Britain “the world leader in low cost clean power generation.”

However, lowering CO2 emissions involves more than throwing up dozens of offshore windfarms. In 2014, 42% of UK emissions came from the built environment. Much of campaigning has therefore focussed on improving the energy efficiency of new buildings.

Here in Durham, the Palatinate Centre uses heat pumps, solar panels and extensive natural light features to reduce energy consumption. 

The goal of operational zero carbon is often used to justify demolishing existing buildings and replacing them with new ones. In fact, Durham University cited this exact reason when proposing to replace Dunelm House (more commonly known as the DSU), as part of its current expansion. 

The Palatine Centre uses solar panels and natural light features to reduce energy consumption

However, the desire to build new neglects consideration of the additional carbon emissions associated with construction – commonly referred to as the embodied energy of a building. 

Embodied energy considers the carbon produced in constructing the building as well as manufacturing the building materials. 

Glass, concrete and steel tend to have higher embodied energies per kilogram than more traditional materials such as fired brick, timber or cob. In particular, the chemical reactions involved in manufacturing cement directly produce carbon dioxide, which is why the cement industry alone is responsible for 8% of all global emissions. 

Determining whether savings in emissions for a new building would be greater than those in improving the efficiency of an existing structure can involve detailed assessment, which itself can be a significant additional cost in designing a project. 

But the UKGBC says that 55% of an average new building’s embodied energy comes from the materials used, so in theory refurbishment could dramatically reduce carbon emissions in comparison to building new. Reuse thus begins to seem a good way to show off your eco-credentials.

Furthermore, it tends to be easier to make the case for refurbishing buildings with aesthetic or historical value. For example, the Grade II listed Hotel Indigo on Old Elvet is a repurposing of a Victorian building originally used as the Durham county hall, which had been empty since 2012.

The system of listing in the UK acts as a counter weight to demolition but it’s not fool proof.

Refurbishment could dramatically reduce carbon emissions

The University of York’s 1960s concrete buildings were able to achieve listed status, and yet the DSU was not – despite the DSU’s connection to Kingsgate Bridge and the world-famous engineer Ove Arup. No doubt part of this is due to general dislike of the Brutalist aesthetic.

Launched in September 2019, the Architects’ Journal “RetroFirst” campaign makes the case to change policy to incentivise retrofit over demolition. It proposes reducing VAT on refurbishment from 20% to 5% to bring it in line with new build projects. This would get publicly funded projects to consider retrofit before demolition. 

As Durham University reassesses their Estates Masterplan in light of Covid-related budget crunches, it would be very interesting to see if they become more open to the value of commissioning inventive repurposing of their existing building stock, rather than taking demolition as the easy way out. 

Image: Anna Main