I will vote Lib Dem in May
By Simon MacAdam
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily of Palatinate.
Before stating my case for supporting the Liberal Democrats in May, I think I need to wipe the slate clean.
Tuition fees. Almost all domestic students reading this will be paying £9,000 a year, and will graduate with £44,035 of student debt on average. So why on earth vote for a party which was instrumental in creating such a regressive policy? Well let me propose a different university funding policy.
Much of university funding should be made by the taxpayer as higher education is a public good.To help with costs, graduates who financially benefit from a university education must pay a small percentage of their income above a reasonable untaxable sum for a maximum of 25 years; for less time if they have paid a substantial amount. If you can’t afford, you don’t pay. This way the government can effectively grant free higher education to a majority of graduates, whilst not incurring the same costs for the taxpayer as having a universal gratuitous policy in which even the wealthiest in society get free university education.
Doesn’t this sound nice? And yes, you’ve guessed it, I lied. This isn’t a different policy – this is the current policy. Amazing what presentation can do isn’t it?
Forget about those nasty words like “debt”, “fees” and “interest”. Let’s call the policy what it actually is– a graduate tax (you know, that thing Labour wanted to implement instead). What other debt do you know of that (1) is not expected to be paid back, (2) does not affect one’s credit rating, (3) cancels after 25 years, and (4) has income-contingent, instead of debt-contingent, interest repayments? There isn’t any.
So why do the media, student representatives and even politicians get it wrong? Alas, it is very possibly the most misconstrued policy of modern times. As far as coalition agreement compromises go, the actual shift from a commitment to scrap tuition fees to the present policy is tiny; in reality this was a victory for the Lib Dems and their principle of fairness. Tuition fees are no basis for not supporting the Lib Dems.
So maybe the policy is fine, but they still broke a promise. My response to that: this is politics.
When no single party wins an election, compromises have to be made. At least this “betrayal” led to a decent policy, unlike the Tory “betrayals” on (1) cutting immigration from the hundreds of thousands to the tens of thousands, (2) balancing the books by 2015, and (3) not undergoing a top-down reform of the NHS, which have imposed nowhere near the same damage as the Liberals have unjustly suffered. But of course these are not betrayals – they are examples of the unfortunate reality of party politics and government.
Far from being a party who have let us down, the Lib Dems put principle before party in entering coalition with the Conservatives, have carried out their four major 2010 policy goals as the minor coalition partner, and have anchored the Tories in the centre ground. They have taken power out of the hands of the likes of Peter Bone MP and Philip Davies MP on the Tory right, for which the country should be eternally grateful. The idea that they ‘have had their time’ is nonsense.
I am convinced that the Lib Dems will be crucial for good government in the UK after 2015. Only they will prevent the Tories cutting taxes for high earners and implementing the remaining 60% of cuts in the next three years, prevent the two Eds from jeopardising the recovery, and prevent the SNP from breaking up the UK. Let’s not punish the Liberal Democrats for tempering the Tories.
If you would like to express a different view to that of this author, please email in a contribution to politics@palatinate.org.uk
Photograph: wikimedia

