I’ll make up my own mind, thanks, Mister Murdoch

Sky and NewsCorp are slowly destroying impartial, intelligent news. Partisan hackery will result. Back in August, James Murdoch, son of media tycoon Rupert Murdoch and chief executive of News Corporation’s European and Asian holdings, and also of BSkyB, unleashed a scathing attack on the BBC and various principles of public service broadcasting. Murdoch claimed to be speaking for free speech and democracy, and attacked BBC expansion, especially online, as a threat to these values.
This comes exactly twenty years after his father launched a similar attack on the BBC. In the intervening time NewsCorp and Sky have become giants of the broadcasting sector, with Sky News picking up multiple awards. NewsCorp papers The Sun and The News of the World have also become the two most widely read newspapers in the country. NewsCorp also owns The Times, and a large stake in ITV.
The Murdochs’ belief in ‘market forces’ as the driving force for ‘consumer choice’ in broadcasting have nothing to do with values of free speech and democracy.
NewsCorp has always been an aggressively monopolising business, and the BBC is the one aspect of broadcasting that they cannot touch. With the decline of newspapers and the rise of the web, the popularity of BBC Online (who doesn’t have it in their favourites bar?) also poses a threat to the Murdochs’ power and influence.
Although I don’t believe the BBC is under threat of being shut down or privatised in the near future, or I certainly hope not, the constant berating of the BBC by NewsCorp owned vehicles, in particular The Sun, as well as other news outlets is undermining respect for the institution, its aims to “inform, educate and entertain”, and the license fee.
I, for one, believe the license fee to be worth almost every penny, lest television is taken over by DFS sales every fifteen minutes. Sure, it has flaws, like Jonathan Ross, but the BBC is still world-leading in broadcasting and journalism.
More alarming amongst Murdoch’s comments however was his belief that news broadcasters should be freed from the obligation to be impartial and be more like the print press.
This seems a particularly dangerous idea given the current mess that American news broadcasting (which is far from impartial) is in over the Obama healthcare plans.
It’s no surprise that the main culprit in this is NewsCorp owned Fox News. If you haven’t watched pillars of news broadcasting such as Bill O’Reilly (who shouts at everyone, even if he agrees with them), Glenn Beck (who actually cries on news television), and Sean Hannity, then I implore you to type these names into YouTube. It really has to be seen to be believed.
Better still, search for ‘LiberalViewer’, a channel that repeatedly exposes Fox News’s bias and sometimes outright creation of facts as it pursues a heavily right-wing and Republican agenda.
It becomes clear why so many Americans have prejudiced views on the Obama healthcare plan (and indeed anything liberal, non-white and foreign) when you find out that Fox News is the number one cable news network in the US.
The false allegations calling Obama’s proposals a publicly funded health system (which it isn’t), saying he is a Nazi or a socialist (which he most definitely is not) and questioning his American citizenship are stirred up mainly by Fox News and similar media.
Fox aren’t the only culprits of partisanship; MSNBC promotes a heavily liberal agenda in response. Between them, these broadcasters have created a huge divide in American political life; Red states and Blue states, conservative and liberal.
American political opinion, thanks to these broadcasters, falls into these two very wide blocks, with no room for personal independent interpretation because television news gives a version of events with strong bias that is already interpreted for you. As a result, America is very much a divided country.
Now this might occur already in British print media, in both The Daily Mail and The Guardian for instance. However, it should stay there.
Television is the quick and easy way to be informed and as a result one is less likely to investigate whether claims made on it are true, whereas fallacies and hypocrisies made by the print press are often exposed brilliantly by publications like Private Eye.
Whether our news broadcasting actually is completely objective or not is not so important, since this is impossible anyway. What matters is that presenting the news via television in this country does not have an overtly political agenda that eliminates independent interpretation, and does not dupe us all into partisan hackery. Long may it stay that way, so we don’t become like the US.