Huis Clos review: ‘haunting’
By Kathy Park
‘Set in Sartrian ‘Hell’, Thorn’s production of Jean- Paul Sartre’s Huis Clos explored themes of selfhood, freedom, and fraught human relationships. Its three main characters, Garcin, Inez and Estelle, each have a desperate dependency on others. It is this futile quest for self-validation, which guides their interactions towards Sartre’s nightmarish conclusion, ‘Hell is other people.’
Huis Clos was the directorial debut for both Freya Palmer and Jack Usher, and well received by the audience. The directors were apt in their choice of actors, who were able to bring out the madness of each character. The bare walls and the fire exit of the empty room in the Gates were put to use in creating a cell in Sartre’s hell by the crew, Nathan Chatelier, Divya Viswanathan, and Mazen Zibara. The simple maneuver of dimming the lights whenever the characters had access to their previous lives, as the darkness brought relief from the glaring lights, subtly conveyed the idea that hell was life without a break.
The play consists of the three inmates coming to terms with their existence and their co-existence in hell. The characters attempt to escape hell through the self-salvation of looking within oneself, the communal salvation of being at the mercy of each other and even a second-death. Yet as they grew in understanding of each others’ sinfulness, trust, faith or love become impossible, and the futility of fighting the permanence of their present state is made clear.
Garcin was played by Adam Murphy, who was able to capture his passionate hatred of his wife in delivering the line: ‘Big tragic eyes.’ Murphy was able to convey the disgust of the character in lines such as ‘Like a sensitive plant’ and ‘You’re soft and slimy … Like an octopus,’ without them becoming merely humorous. The poignancy of Garcin’s desire for dignity in death: ‘If I face my death courageously, I’ll prove I am no coward’ and even in hell: ’that one person’s faith would save me,’ was evoked by the actor’s control over his voice. Murphy was able to act well with the other characters, contributing to their collective hysteria that came with facing the reality of their situation, and declaring with bitter honesty that: ‘We’re naked, naked right through and, and I can see into your heart.’ Garcin is ultimately crippled by the word ‘coward,’ but one may question whether it was the imposition of this word on his identity – as the Sartrean idea of other people sacrificing your identity implies – or his own understanding of the truth of his identity as a coward which stifles him.
Yasmin Jones excelled as Estelle, capturing her seeming naivety and underlying awareness of reality in her insistence in moments, such as when she insisted on substituting the word ‘absentee’ for ‘dead’ to describe herself. Jones was able to develop her character from lightheartedly reminiscing the words of her lover: ‘my glancing stream, my crystal,’ to screaming out the words: ‘the crystal’s shattered to bits.’ In doing so she presents not only the beauty of the crystal, but also the fact that both the identity she has created and the perception of others, as the reflective nature of the crystal implies, are of no use in hell. The actress delivered characteristic lines for Estella such as: ‘Somehow I feel we’ve never been so much alive as now,’ which though ironic rings true, and her desperate plea for attention: ’Look at me. Please look. Touch me. Touch me. There!’ Estelle epitomises the vanity and dependency of human beings on other people’s perception of them. Again, one may ask whether it is the other people sacrificing Estelle’s identity, and thus ‘hell’ or whether it is her own vanity and self.
Georgia Bowen Evans was a mysterious and knowing Inez, strongest when she was able to support the other actors. Inez is explicitly presented as the mirror to Estelle in one scene: ‘I’m your lark-mirror my dear and you can’t escape me,’ and thus one may argue that she encroaches upon Estelle’s identity. However, she is the most perceptive in that she is able to awake the others if not express the truth that they are already aware of. Inez is the one to admit her sinfulness: ‘Human feeling. That’s beyond my range. I’m rotten to the core,’ and the others’ hypocrisy in denying it: ‘What’s the point of play-acting, trying to throw dust in each other’s eyes? We’re all tarred with the same brush.’ At times Evans was fierce in her retorts: ‘To forget about the others? How utterly absurd! I feel you there, in every pore,’ yet at other times she sang calmly, though morbidly, of public executions. One of the most memorable scenes was between Inez and Estelle, when Inez broke into Estelle’s speech: ‘Nothing on earth belongs to you any more,’ powerfully without shouting.
The play ends with the prisoners laughing hysterically on the word ‘forever,’ as though the reality of their situation cannot be dealt without an appearance of madness. What may be disturbing is that as the inmates choose to remain in their cell, even then seem to have the option of leaving, and Garcin’s words: ‘well, let’s get on with it,’ are accompanied by a blackout, the audience are also locked into the darkness. The audience might not to associate themselves with the ‘criminals’ they have witnessed on stage, but the truth of Inez’s words: ‘There were days when you peered into yourself, into the secret places of your heart, and what you saw there made you faint with horror,’ is haunting and one may envy the characters in having been able to be honest about their darkness’s but also walk out of the play with the possibility and hope of salvation in our own ways: in relationships, success, fulfillment or in Christ.
Photograph: Nathan Chatelier (edited by: Samuel Kirkman)
