HS2: Manchester to London at top speed
by Tom Dimaio

First and foremost, would a high-speed rail link between Manchester and London be a good thing? Yes, of course it would. This is obviously not the argument that should be focused on.
The real question of course is a more financial one. Is £32 billion pounds too much to spend on this project? Probably. If an investment of this size is made into our railways, is HS2 the right way to do it? Perhaps not.
As a Durham student who travels by train frequently, it has become apparent that there are numerous problems with our railways that could be fixed with this investment.
Firstly, the price of train tickets have been steadily increasing year by year to the stage where if one wished to travel from Durham to a London terminal it could cost as much as £150. Whereas train fares for Durham students are costly, this is not the area that could be best helped with investment.
High-speed rail is meant to boost business and help the economy. This could best be done by slashing consumer costs, not journey times. In an age where train fares and technological capability are rising year on year, investment is being planned in the wrong area.
If the government were to invest in the railways, they should do so by subsidising commuter ticket prices.  If this were done it would provide a key boost to the economy, as big-spending city workers would have more cash to pump into other areas. This comes alongside the obvious benefit of increased demand for train travel, again boosting our economy.
The point about technological advancement is also key. As smartphones and laptops evolve, so does the capability for an individual to be productive outside of the office. This certainly means that there is less need for shorter journey times as work no longer begins and ends at the office door.
Spectator columnist James Delingpole quite rightly pointed out on the BBC’s question time that people “use the train as their office, it doesn’t matter if they can get from Manchester to London in 10 seconds.”  Although 10 seconds seems ambitious, I do believe that this observation could prove to be the crux of the matter.
Finally a word must be said about this idea of stimulating business in the north by creating this high-speed rail link to Manchester. Whereas in principle this makes sense, what might instead happen is that we see the complete reverse effect occur. Yes, HS2 would create a link from the South to the North, it is however a two-way street. It might also act as a passage from the North to set up business in the less economically damaged half of the country. From the government’s point of view, I’m not sure whether this would be a wise risk to take.
This £32 billion pound project constitutes a huge opportunity for the government to make sound capital investment. However, it seems that a focus on speed rather than cost could be an unwise move.
Photograph: Flickr ID – Jon Curnow
