How to solve a problem like Syria?

by Matthew Beebee

syria-4-big

The situation in Syria has been raging for over two bloody years now.

What began as a popular demonstration against Bashar al-Assad’s government, demanding political reform and an end to the 1963 state of emergency, has descended into brutal civil war.

Assad’s violent crackdown on peaceful protesters forced the popular demonstration into armed rebellion, leading to a conflict that has claimed over 100,000 lives and 1.7 million refugees flooding into neighbouring countries such as Turkey and Lebanon.

As the conflict has dragged on, the situation on the ground has become increasingly complex and confused.

Initially the opposition forces comprised outraged civilian protestors and defected soldiers under the banner of the ‘Free Syrian Army’. But since late 2011, Islamist forces have joined the opposition fight – with reported links to al-Qaeda – as have the Shia militia Hezbollah on the side of the Syrian government.

Kurdish fighters in the north of Syria also became increasingly involved in late 2012, fighting both the Syrian government’s forces and the Islamist opposition.

Such a mix of combatants, with different goals and hopes, has presented confusion for foreign onlookers and their ability to respond.

syria-3

But the situation is worsening. The Syrian government allegedly launched a chemical attack in the Eastern Ghouta region on August 21st, killing 355 people and injuring more than 3000 according to Medecins Sans Frontiers.

UN investigators are seeking to determine whether chemical weapons were used, albeit after a five day delay, yet their mandate does not allow them to determine who was responsible. The Syrian government, via its Foreign Minister, has denied the use of chemical weapons.

The USA, however, is clear that the use of chemical weapons is undeniable and seems convinced Assad’s government is to blame, a view shared by the French and British governments. President Obama warned back in 2012 that a chemical attack would cross ‘the red line’ and result in ‘enormous consequences’ for Syria.

Verbal response to the chemical attack has been plentiful. US Secretary of State, John Kerry, has condemned the attack as a ‘moral obscenity’ while Defence Secretary, Chuck Hagel, claims the US are ready to launch a strike when a presidential decision is reached.

David Cameron has recalled Parliament to debate and vote on responding to the situation in Syria while also drawing up contingency plans for military action and condemning the attack. The Arab League also blames Assad for the chemical attack and has called for the UN to take action.

What appears certain is that the international community has reached a stage where it believes enough is enough and inaction is no longer viable.

So what action could the international community take?

‘The more likely option is missile strikes against chemical facilities’

The first option, ‘boots on the ground’ military intervention and military aid in the form of weapons and tactical advice, seems off the cards. While this would give the opposition forces a superior advantage, Western powers want to avoid deploying soldiers for geopolitical reasons and there is much confusion over the different opposition factions.

Who would the West arm or its troops support? With Islamist fighters linked to al-Qaeda in the combat zone, arming the rebel forces en masse risks placing weapons in the hands of an enemy the West has been fighting since 2001.

The second and more likely option is targeted missile strikes on chemical weapon facilities and government targets. Such attacks would be quick and sufficiently devastating to send out a clear message that chemical warfare will not be tolerated by the international community.

syria-1

While the intervention of choice may be all but decided, acquiring legal backing for it is another thing entirely. What is needed is a UN resolution, which is unlikely given Russian support for Assad and its record of blocking previous UN action in Syria.

William Hague, the British Foreign Secretary, has argued action could be taken without a UN resolution. Syria has signed the 1925 Geneva Protocol banning chemical weapons and, if it is proven that the government used the weapons, this could form some legal basis for intervention.

But the doctrine of ‘Responsibility to Protect’ seems the most likely legal root if a UN resolution fails. This doctrine argues that a state is responsible for protecting its population from humanitarian crisis, and in the event of a state failing to do so, the international community can act.

Although not as legally binding as a resolution, ‘R2P’ could give some justification provided the case is presented strongly enough. But this doctrine hinges on a response being proportionate and, crucially, certain of success – something that cannot be guaranteed even with a clear objective given the confusing situation inside Syria.

What is certain is that the crisis in Syria has reached a tipping point. All are appalled by the scenes there. But without a clear objective, strong evidence and legal justification for intervention, any action in Syria will be seen as a form of aggression. The West can ill-afford the situation to escalate further.

Photographs: Syria Freedom