How Secure is the Council?
By Zoe Haylock
The UN can be intimidating. This is especially true for the UN Security Council, the most powerful and controversial of all the UN bodies.
The Security Council offers a platform for countries to debate international military action and issue binding resolutions, allowing states with severe political and economic differences to work together on the most pressing global problems. Some of their peacekeeping efforts have stabilised countries engulfed in conflict and provided accountability to states that subvert international law.
However, whether the Council fulfils its very concept, to be a protector of security and peace, can be debated. Ten of the fifteen members alternate every two years and the other five permanent members have the right to veto which can alone completely overrule resolutions. There is little accountability or public say; power is retained in what were once the world’s most dominant states.
The composition of the council has been largely unchanged since 1971, when the People’s Republic of China took up the permanent position. Unsurprisingly, the body is still entrenched in Cold War ideology. Moreover, the vetoes show how Russia and China seem to work together to block resolutions in areas such as the Middle East and reports of genocide. This makes the Council appear as a playground for national ideology politics, rather than a means of securing peace.
The Council has been criticised for its lack of effective intervention. The Rwandan genocide of 1994, defeats in the Balkans war and allegations of UN peacekeepers assaulting the people they should protect all put doubt in the Council’s effectiveness.
We can kid ourselves that the Council is harmonious and works as efficiently but the national politics of the permanent members cause conflict. It limits the progressive nature of the body and engulfs it in controversy. This institution has great powers and little accountability. We should all be active in questioning the state of the Council and its role in the world in order to improve it.
Image by WordRidden via Flickr
