How not to be President: an Idiot’s guide

By Isabella Craddock

On May 24th, the United States passed 100,000 deaths from COVID-19. Despite representing only 4.25% of the global population, the US leads the world in both deaths borne from and confirmed cases of COVID-19 globally, just shy of 30% for each category.

At the forefront of the mind of the American public is the question of how the President is protecting and leading his nation through this time of crisis. Unfortunately for the US, Trump’s inconsistent federal response coupled with his dissemination of unreliable information through his social media has created a landscape of fear, uncertainty, and unsafety for the people of the United States.

A leadership vacuum has emerged with Trump’s failure to produce a cohesive plan to protect the US from what he has dubbed the “Chinese virus.” In the place of developing a testing strategy or enforcing a national lockdown, Trump’s comments throughout January and February focused largely on how Americans were to be protected from those coming from China, where COVID-19 was first identified. In a January 22 World Economic Forum interview with CNBC’s Joe Kernen, Trump stated that “We have it totally under control. It’s one person coming in from China, and we have it under control. It’s going to be just fine.” Just one day earlier in a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention press briefing, Nancy Messonnier – director of the National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases at the CDC – stated that “We do expect additional cases in the United States and globally.”

A leadership vacuum has emerged with Trump’s failure to produce a cohesive plan to protect the US

Despite having been briefed by the CDC prior to his January 22nd interview, Trump downplayed the threat of the novel coronavirus on a global stage. Moving into February, his response centred around China, first applauding President Xi Jinping and claiming that the US was taking necessary precautions to distance themselves from those travelling from Wuhan but later in February and March, using China as a scapegoat for the US’s rising number of confirmed cases. Most recently, on May 28th, Trump tweeted “All over the World the CoronaVirus, a very bad ‘gift’ from China, marches on. Not good!” His response has been nothing but inconsistent, shifting blame away from himself and his Republican party to China and “the Radical Left Lamestream Media, together with their partner, the Do Nothing Democrats,” as he refers to them.

In the wake of Trump’s inconsistency, state governors took centre stage, with New York’s Andrew Cuomo and California’s Gavin Newsom, representing a combined 18% of the US population as of 2019, being prime examples. While Trump was tweeting, Cuomo and Newsom were listening to science and locking down. 2 months later, Trump is taking the credit for these state initiatives, tweeting on May 16th:

“We’ve done a GREAT job on Covid response, making all Governors look good, some fantastic (and that’s OK), but the Lamestream Media doesn’t want to go with that narrative, and the Do Nothing Dems talking point is to say only bad about ‘Trump’. I made everybody look good, but me!”

It would seem that Trump is more concerned with his image than with his country.

Trump is more concerned with his image than with his country

Furthermore, Trump’s attitude as a leader amidst crisis has not bode well for protection of the public. Trump refuses to wear a mask despite CDC guidelines, has tweeted unconfirmed, pseudo-medical advice about taking the antimalarial drug hydroxychloroquine, postulated that the virus would disappear with warmer weather, has expressed support for anti-lockdown protests in Michigan – tweeting “LIBERATE MICHIGAN!” on April 17, and on the same day that US deaths reached 100,000, tweeting that “Schools in our country should be opened ASAP. Much very good information now available.” Trump’s words directly contradict FDA, CDC, and state government advice, inviting fear and uncertainty into what has become one of the most deadly episodes of America’s history.

While Trump’s response is deeply flawed, he is not solely responsible for the protection of the American people – enter Congress. On a Federal level, the largest response is the proposed Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economy Security Act (the CARES Act). Introduced into the Senate by Republican Senators Mitch McConnell and six others and pledging around $2.3 trillion, the act is set “to provide emergency assistance and health care response for individuals, families, and businesses affected by the 2020 coronavirus pandemic,” as stated in its first line. However, the formidable $2.3 trillion allocates just shy of 7% toward public health in the form of infrastructure and equipment; the tools most urgent to contain the spread of the coronavirus. Despite the first line of the act declaring that the aim is to support the health care response, around 93% of the budget is spent elsewhere.

As a student and young person living in the United States, I do not believe that Trump or the GOP has the American public’s best interest at heart. I may not be part of the most vulnerable group, but that does not mean that these 100,000 deaths do not bring fear and anxiety to the lives of all those around me. On a Federal level the United States is failing and Americans – ill-advised, misinformed, and scared as a result of their President’s words – are paying the price.

Image: Gage Skidmore via Flickr