How effective is UK support to refugees?

By Duru Akin

Recently, UK Government announced the ‘Homes for Ukraine’ scheme, which allows UK individuals, charities, community groups and businesses to provide Ukrainian refugees with accommodation. On 14th March, The Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, Michael Gove, launched a webpage for sponsors to record their interest. Since then, over 100,000 people have signed up for the scheme. To benefit from the it, either the prospective sponsor or the person wishing to be sponsored must complete the visa application on the webpage. Whilst this shows the heart of the British public, it exposes a double standard in Government over which refugees are offered help and in what manner.

Upon the launch of the scheme, Gove made the following remark: “The United Kingdom has a long and proud history of helping others in their hour of need and our new Homes for Ukraine scheme offers a lifeline to those who have been forced to flee.” Although a true observation, Gove’s statement does not cover ongoing conflicts in other parts of the world, namely the Syrian Civil War.

In the case of other refugees the same efficacy was not adopted

A war that has been going on since 15th March 2011, UNHCR Refugee Data records that only 11,422 Syrian refugees were allowed to enter the UK – an incomparable number to that of Ukrainian refugees gathered in just 10 days. Not to mention, in 2015 David Cameron told MPs that the UK would accept up to 20,000 refugees from Syria by 2020 – a claim left unproved.

Of course, Syrians are not the only under-represented refugees: Iraqis, Iranians, and many other refugees from a somewhat similar geography were all treated differently than the Ukrainians. Additionally, UNHCR statistics reveal that as of mid-2021 there were 135,912 refugees in the UK, 83,489 of which were pending asylum cases. Clearly, the Government is able to offer help of great significance in such short notice, yet in the case of other refugees the same efficacy was not adopted.

Another issue worth noting is the classification of Ukrainians and its relation to integration. Local Government Association Chairman, James Jamieson said “councils will be central in helping families settle into their communities and access public services, including schools, public health and other support, including access to trauma counselling.” While it is tremendously difficult for refugees to obtain and void for asylum seekers in the general sense, incoming Ukrainians are provided with it. So why is it that Ukrainian refugees are held somewhat separate from refugees of other races and ethnicities?

Sanctuary Foundation Director, Dr Krish Kandiah mentioned that “in 1939 the people of the UK opened their hearts and homes to children fleeing from the Nazis and we look back on that ‘Kinder Transport’ as an act of culture-defining hospitality.” While this is a wonderful historical example of the UK’s efforts at helping others, Dr Kandiah’s choice of words is rather thought-provoking: approaching humanitarian crises from a perspective of  ‘geographical-limits’ draws the same peculiar contrast between Ukrainian and other refugees as mentioned earlier in the article.

Is it a matter concerning ‘Europeanness?’

Bearing this in mind, the unavoidable question regarding UK residents opening their homes to Ukrainians entering the country with the scheme strikes us once again: why is it that the UK Government encourages residents to house – specifically Ukrainian – refugees in their homes now, and not for other refugees before? Is it a matter concerning ‘Europeanness?’

According to rules and regulations, when a person is given refugee status, they have just 28 days to find accommodation and apply for mainstream benefits before they are evicted from asylum accommodation. At this stage, many refugees become homeless. This situation causes complex ongoing issues which multiply every year. Hypothetically speaking, integrating the idea of ‘Europeanness’ with this perspective, having a more efficacious Ukrainian help scheme where people are already given accommodation upon arrival seems a deliberate move.

It is brilliant how UK people are immensely eager to help Ukrainians forced to flee their homes in any way they can. The mere fact that UK residents are willing to welcome Ukrainian families in their households mirrors how humanity comes before any precept. However, on a state-level spectrum, several discrepancies regarding the treatment of different refugees evoke questions.

Image: Maria Teneva via Unsplash