“Holy grail of mathematics” found?

By Holly Parkinson

On September 24th, Sir Michael Atiyah presented what he claimed to be a  “simple proof” for the Riemann Hypothesis, an achievement described as the “holy grail of mathematics” if shown to be true. However, the proof, which relies on a seemingly unrelated piece of Physics, has been met with scepticism from the mathematical community.

The Riemann Hypothesis concerns prime numbers (integers only divisible by 1 and themselves) and finding a pattern in their distribution. In 1859, German Mathematician Bernhard Riemann discovered that solutions for a complex mathematical function (known as the Riemann Zeta function and responsible for ‘-1/12’ memes) would act as a guide if it could be shown that the real-part of all values were equal to one half. As prime numbers pervade all aspects of maths, a correct proof would constitute an enormous breakthrough. Unfortunately, the conjecture has frustrated mathematicians since it was first put forward. One of the Millennium Prize Problems from Clay Mathematics Institute – and so eligible for a $1 million prize – it has attracted many attempts to solve it, though all have been either subtly flawed or easily dismissed.

The announcement has been met with considerable friction from the mathematical community

Sir Atiyah cannot be so easily dismissed.  A retired British-Lebanese academic, he has been described by his peers as a ‘wizard of a mathematician’; he was President of the Royal Society from 1990 to 1995 and holds both the Fields Medal and Abel Prize: some of mathematics’ highest honours. Nevertheless, what he claims as proof has more than a whiff of crankiness:  it takes up no more than half an A4 page and is prefaced with the almost cocky ‘I believe it will live up to this challenge, and this paper will provide the proof’.  A ‘proof by contradiction’, the work introduces and uses an as yet unpublished paper on the Todd Function, named after one of Sir Atiyah’s teachers. By assuming the hypothesis is false, and using the function to describe a physical value that describes the interactions between charged particles, he claims to have reached a logical contradiction.

As could be expected due to the difficulty of the problem and the shortness of the proof,  the announcement has been met with considerable friction from the mathematical community, with most doubting its validity. Indeed, NBC News described the problem as “unsolved for almost 160 years [and] probably still is”. This isn’t new for Sir Atiyah, whose recent paper regarding the 6 Sphere (a 7-dimensional sphere) was heavily criticised by British mathematician Robert Bryant.

Winning the money is far less simple than presenting one’s proof and receiving a cheque: Atiyah’s work must stand for two years in order to pass. If deemed correct, The Riemann Hypothesis will become only the second of the seven Millennium Prize Problems to be solved, the other being the Poincaré Conjecture, which was correctly proved by Grigori Perelman in 2003.

 

Photograph: ICM 2018 via Flickr