HIV and blood donors: science or discrimination?
By Krystian Jonski
On 3rd November 2020, Public Health England released its statistics for HIV diagnoses in It showed that, among the men who have sex with men – MSM – community, there were around 1,700 new detections, compared to 1,600 among heterosexuals. Not only are rates at their lowest since 2000, but it’s the first time the numbers have been so close to each other. This is great news, but it begs a question. If these figures are so similar, then why do MSM have to wait three months to donate blood from the last time they had anal sex when heterosexuals don’t?
It is hard not to feel discriminated against when, cup of tea in hand, you mull over this data. You can be in a monogamous, HIV-negative, relationship but still forbidden from donating based on falling under a far too generalised MSM umbrella. The rules laid out are obviously not dictated solely by the stats, but by the people who so meticulously number crunch over them. I struggle to accept that lurking somewhere in the decision making isn’t the, at the very least subconscious, prejudice from an epidemical past we have long since made leaps and strides away from.
It is hard not to feel discriminated against
The 80s saw the inception of the HIV/AIDS epidemic at a time when safe sex wasn’t as widely practised, let alone taught. The initial predominance of HIV/AIDS within the gay community provided the world with a perfectly unwitting minority scapegoat, where terms like ‘GRID’ and ‘gay cancer’ are still fresh wounds among those who were alive at the time.
In 2016, the numbers of MSM against heterosexual people testing positive for HIV was 2810 versus 2354, yet MSM still had to wait a whole year from last having sex before being able to donate. Simply because the numbers may have turned a leaf for the new millennium does not mean that the harmful misgivings followed suit.
Beside a probing pre-donation questionnaire, all blood donations have samples sent for computer analysis – better not to put your recipient’s life in the hands of the first-time donor who thinks they are O- after asking their mum ten years back. These tests happen to screen for a petri dish selection of blood transmissible diseases, and a HIV detection – which is at minimum 99.8% accurate – at this stage leads to the prevention
of a possible contamination catastrophe.
Surely if these methods are so rigorous, we shouldn’t have to worry about anyone donating and the rules are conclusively discriminatory. As fanciful an idea as this may be, it transpires that from the time of infection, HIV can take up to 12 weeks to be detectable in the blood. A three-month waiting period from last having sex no longer seems a remotely far-fetched idea, quite the opposite, but it doesn’t begin to explain why before 2017 MSM had to wait four times that long.
HIV can take up to 12 weeks to be detectable
Perhaps the final piece of the puzzle lies in HIV transmission rates by route. In blood transfusions this is at a huge 90%, whereas receptive anal lies at 0.5% and 0.1% for vaginal. I can neither believe nor reasonably see a scientific explanation as to why only MSM are targeted by the three-month rule, when heterosexual people are also more than capable of performing anal sex.
However, an end is in sight. From this summer, donations are going to finally stop being catered to broad brush stroke demographics and instead toward the individual; rather than being prodded for your orientation, you will simply be asked if you participate in anal. Further, providing you’re in a minimum of three months monogamous relationship, you will be able to donate regardless of the sex you are having.
This may not absolve the past decade’s inconsistent and often anger-inducing rules, but it’s important to welcome positive change. Not being able to answer the call that the country needs more blood, while understanding that you are safe and capable of doing so, may have been a
disheartening journey, but the destination to a far more equal and destigmatising set of rules is finally in sight.

