History reforms bring welcome changes

by Niall Oddymichael-goveresized1

Reading Francesca Moll’s diatribe against proposed changes to the school history curriculum (Palatinate 749, 28th February), I was reminded of the dangers of using The Guardian as your only source of information about current affairs.  I was also left wondering whether her obvious ideological antipathy to Michael Gove caused her to misunderstand the reforms or merely to misrepresent them in her article for rhetorical purpose.

The new curriculum has been presented by some as a right-wing plot to indoctrinate young people with a patriarchal, nationalistic, monocultural and British-centred understanding of history that ignores women and minority groups at the expense of white men such as Churchill and Nelson, and ignores critical thinking and analysis in favour of hard facts.

It is a view that is, frankly, ridiculous.  Allow me to quote some of the specified aims of the curriculum, which should serve to debunk Gove’s critics. Pupils should ‘know and understand the broad outlines of European and world history’.  So the planned curriculum is not guilty of a narrow focus on Britain.

Furthermore, pupils should ‘understand historical concepts such as continuity and change, cause and consequence, similarity, difference and significance, and use them to make connections, draw contrasts, analyse trends, frame historically-valid questions and create their own structured accounts’.  So the proposals, then, are not guilty of rejecting critical thinking.

Additionally, pupils should ‘understand how evidence is used rigorously to make historical claims, and discern how and why contrasting arguments and interpretations of the past have been constructed’.  So to the charge of presenting only one view of history we must find the defendant not guilty.

And pupils should understand ‘the connections between local, regional, national and international history; between cultural, economic, military, political, religious and social history’.  With this, Francesca Moll’s assertion that the proposed curriculum seeks to propagate the ‘Great Man’ approach to history is revealed to be – to put it simply – wrong.

Taking a look at the suggested content of the curriculum, we find women in abundance: Elizabeth Fry, Florence Nightingale and Annie Besant to name a few.  Slavery is included, as is twentieth-century immigration and individuals from minority backgrounds such as Mary Seacole and Olaudah Equiano.  This is hardly as narrow-minded as some have suggested.

Above all, critics are forgetting one crucial element – teachers.  (It is not surprising that they have been forgotten because those on the left tend to overlook individuals, seeing only institutions, like the state, or what they regard as homogenous groups, like the ‘working class’.) The curriculum is just a document; it is individual teachers who will bring it to life.

The old adage that the French education minister knows what all pupils in France are doing at any given time on any given day can certainly not be applied to the British context. Even within a national curriculum teachers are given a huge scope for personal choice when it comes to delivering lessons (even more so in free schools and academies, Gove’s flagship policies).  If any history lessons are insular or narrowly focussed then that will be down to the teacher concerned.  Many of those in that noble profession will be able to deliver fantastically wide-ranging lessons, using the new curriculum as a guide.

Not that this curriculum is in place.  It is a consultation document, designed to encourage discussion, and anyone who is interested can provide feedback until 16th April.  Whilst I’m broadly supportive of Gove’s aims, I do feel that too much content is prescribed and that teachers should be given greater freedom.

Let’s hope that Michael Gove considers all constructive feedback that is raised during this process of consultation but remains undeterred from his necessary ambition of promoting better standards.

He should not give way to those who appear not to have read the actual curriculum document (or have done so but choose to distort what is written therein) and who would have their own political agenda pursued in schools.