Higher Education: limited to the rich and privileged?
By Ellie Rylance
The Government has outlined plans that would prevent prospective students from accessing student loans for university if they failed their Maths and English GCSEs or did not get two A levels at Grade E. This has been met with considerable backlash amid concerns that it will limit access to higher education to those who are wealthy.
The wealth attainment gap is well documented. Speaking to The Guardian, Lee Elliot Major, a professor of social mobility at the University of Exeter, said that: “children from the lowest fifth of family income backgrounds are five times more likely to leave school without passing GCSE English and Maths than those from the highest fifth of incomes.”
Denying students on the basis of grades will disproportionately restrict students from disadvantaged backgrounds
Statistics obtained by The Guardian reflect this, 29% of pupils in England do not achieve a grade 4 in GCSE English and Maths, and this rises to 48% among disadvantaged households. While it is important to note that only 8% of English 18-year-olds accepted onto university courses did not achieve a grade 4 in English and Maths in 2020, these measures would disproportionately target disadvantaged students who rely on student loans to access higher education.
Additionally, the attainment gap between pupils on free school meals and those not on free school meals is continuing to widen. The Guardian reported in 2021 that while those on free school meals “received double the rate of top trades gained in 2019. But the gap between them and those not on free school meals increased from eight percentage points to 12%. Additionally, The Times wrote that in 2021, three in ten GCSE results were top grades, but this was twice as high (61%) at private schools and even higher (68%) at selective state schools.
There is a misconception that GCSE’s are an accurate reflective of a student’s academic ability or their ability to thrive in a university environment. As a recent article in Vice sought to demonstrate this is not always the case. The article spoke to current and former GCSE students who had failed their Maths and English GCSEs: Tom Neilson, 31, said: “I failed my Maths GCSE three times and went on to get a first in Music Managament.” Aviah Sarah Day, 34, said: “I was homeless during my GCSEs and got an E in Maths. I went on to do a PhD and now work as a University Lecturer”. Cheryl Fyfield, 26 said: “I failed my Maths and English GCSE because I was in hospital during my exams. I’m now a student nurse. It’s terrifying to know I wouldn’t be able to get a loan to do my nursing training because of this”.
This risk creating a two-tier system of education based on wealth
What contributions to scholarship would be sacrificed if other students like Neilson, Day or Fyfield were denied the opportunity to attend university due to a lack of student loans?
This also introduces another key issue: students with extenuating circumstances. Those with special circumstances can apply for special consideration, but AQA states that in these cases ‘a small percentage’ is added to the raw mark. Would this ‘small percentage’ be enough to make any significant difference for a student in the position Fyfield found herself in?
It is clear that denying student loans on the basis of grades will disproportionately restrict students from disadvantaged backgrounds and students with extenuating circumstances from being able to access university education.
Alistair Jarvis CBE, chief executive of Universities UK, said: “Government should expand opportunity, not constrain it. Placing a cap on aspiration by reducing the number of places for people to study at university is bad for individuals, the economy and society.”
This comes at a time when the number of 18-year-olds from the most disadvantaged areas pursuing higher education has risen to 28%, compared with just 18% in 2013.
The Department of Education said that the measures are designed to restrict the growth of “poor-quality, low-cost courses” and because the Government hopes to incentivise more young people to pursue apprenticeships.
But is it right for the Government to disproportionately restrict the options of those from disadvantaged backgrounds or who may have had extenuating circumstances? It also risks creating a two-tier system of education based on wealth with students that are from a wealthier background will be more likely to be able to attend university regardless of failing grades. Thus, you could have two students with the same grades, one of whom is able to attend university because they can afford to do so without a student loan, and another who is unable to attend because they cannot afford to do so without a student loan.

Image: Got Credit via Creative Commons.
