Hey big spender: does Durham University spend too much on art?
YES by Zoe Haylock
University is about education. Durham’s funding should be used to best serve the students and our education. Although art is important, is it important enough to be given the £2 million funding it received between 2008 and 2015? No, it is not.
The idea that this art expenditure is unqualified is true enough to itself, let alone with it occurring in our current context. Student accommodation fees are increasing by 3.5% next year, student grants are limited and university fees are at an all-time high. I doubt prospective students glaring at the gargantuan fees are going to care about the market price of the art they see when walking to their lecture hall. Surplus funding should be spent on financial support, educational advancement, and making Durham a more inclusive and diverse society.
This surely is a symptom of the elitism within Durham. I love art, but I understand that the majority do not. Even more upsetting is that many of the prized works Durham has are housed in Hollingside House. Used for Vice-Chancellors and business, this location is not easily accessible to students. It seems that Durham has lost sight of its most important asset: its students.
A more economical and interesting alternative would be to utilise the artwork of Durham students. There are artists everywhere among our student population. The artists here are diverse, testing, experimental and probably much more equipped in engaging students in art than the artists we see on display. Durham also doesn’t offer an art degree. This makes it even more important that students should be given the opportunity to display their work and others the opportunity to admire it.
Art is important but Durham is wrong to assume that it is a pivotal part of our lives. Students want better financial equality, inclusion, and a more valuable educational experience.
NO by Stella Botes
In reaction to revelations about University art spending, students told Palatinate that ‘I came here to get a degree, not to look at ‘geosculptures’, and ‘I’ve literally never seen any [art]’. These platitudes speak to a different issue than the transparency of art spending, and reveal a more deeply ingrained problem; a lack of awareness and appreciation for the worth of art.
Buying art is characterised as frivolous and impractical. Education, the factory-like attainment of a respectable degree, is made into a monolith in the lives of students, pushing to the sidelines any advocacy for an integrative approach that includes that which might be ‘useless’ in our exams. We protest the quasi-industrialisation of our education system, but fail to protect and actively reject attempts to diversify that same system with investment in art.
Art is an investment, not simply burning money. Art pays for itself as artists grow and reputations change, and as it enhances the environment around it. It is an investment that is much to be preferred to the alternative, often unethical, areas of investment in which the university could (and does) choose to spend its money.
Certainly, there is an issue of accessibility, but if the collection were made more accessible then we could truly begin to take advantage of its educational and moral value. Having worked with the collection myself, I am aware of its richness and diversity, and of the hard work of curators in trying to manage and preserve art. In fact, those same curators might argue that this is a problem not of accessibility but engagement; art is speckled throughout our colleges and lecture halls, the Oriental Museum is an increasingly dynamic international institution overlooked because ‘it’s a long walk from town’, and the Durham Arts festival and Bailey art tours were both hosted this year to increase accessibility.
I don’t doubt that many students at Durham enjoy art. Were we to all become engaged in the art around us, we might realise its value, stimulate projects for its use within the community. Quite simply, we might start to enjoy it and recognise the value it brings to our lives at Durham.
Image ‘Cubism’ (1937) by Picasso, by Ian Burt via Flickr and Creative Commons
