Helping or Hindering?

By Elise Boothroyd

In late 2014 it appeared that the era of the YouTube novel would come to a swift and dramatic end after YouTuber and blogger Zoe Sugg (better known as Zoella) came under fire for producing her debut book, Girl Online, with the assistance of a ghost-writer. But since then, Sugg and other British YouTubers have continued to release hugely successful novels, with Louise Pentland’s Wilde About The Girl and Carrie Hope Fletcher’s When The Curtain Falls, both published in the last few months. Clearly, YouTuber authors are not going away any time soon.

Could it be that young readers are in fact picking up poor writing habits

The fact that YouTubers now write books almost by default is arguably most detrimental to their own fans, many of whom are children and teenagers. Such young viewers are perhaps more easily manipulated to buy books purely because they are covered with the names and faces of their favourite internet celebrities, whether or not they were responsible for the words inside. This potential exploitation raises multiple concerns. Aside from wasting their money, could it be that young readers are in fact picking up poor writing habits by consuming literature churned out at a rate of knots by untrained YouTubers or pressured ghost-writers? Or could this doorway into the literary world open up a whole new range of possibilities to further their education? To find out, I decided to flip through a few of these books myself.

We shouldn’t assume they are incapable of writing

I have to admit, I was pleasantly surprised. Granted, I have yet to come across a YouTuber’s book that could be described as a literary masterpiece, but the majority are fun, relatable and easy to follow. If anything it is going to encourage young people to have a read; these books stand a pretty good chance. And encourage people to read they have; Fletcher’s most recent novel was a Sunday Times Top Five bestseller, and Pentland’s soared to the top spot of the same chart.

I can only hope that some copies of these books inspired a wider interest in literature. This positive outcome would totally negate any worries about YouTubers’ banal plot lines, lack of impeccable writing style or questionable authorship. Besides, unlike Girl Online, there is no indication that Fletcher and Pentland’s novels were ghost-written; Fletcher, who is also a West End star, has dreamed of writing a book since childhood. Clearly, it is possible for YouTubers to be multi-talented, and we shouldn’t assume they are incapable of writing purely because this isn’t the primary reason for their fame.

The practice of publishing YouTubers’ books could still be considered damaging from the perspective of other authors. It must be particularly frustrating for committed novelists to receive rejection after rejection, only to witness ‘vloggers’ release hugely successful books, in some cases without stringing together a single sentence. Indeed, Zoella’s ghost-written Girl Online sold more copies in its first week than any other debut book since records began.

This success is hardly surprising given the size of her existing fanbase. Whilst Zoella has amassed an astounding 11.9 million subscribers on her main channel, Pentland and Fletcher are not doing too badly with 2.5 million and 650,000 subscribers apiece. It may seem unfair that these large audiences enable YouTubers’ offerings to overshadow other books. However, these sales are surely giving the book industry a much-needed boost, which may well benefit other authors in the long run.

These internet superstars have encouraged younger viewers to read

Whether YouTubers’ novels are exploiting audiences and stealing the thunder of other writers or not, it’s not entirely their fault. YouTubers are offered book deals because publishing houses know that their books will sell. Perhaps publishers should maintain the moral high ground by refusing these deals and instead let them stick to what they know best – making videos. However, sales figures prove that audiences want to buy YouTubers’ books, and in all honesty, their books aren’t half-bad. These internet superstars have encouraged younger viewers to read, some for the first time in a while, and I, for one, am not complaining.

Photo credit: Louise Pentland and Zoe Sugg via Gage Skidmore, Flickr via Creative Commons.