Have they lost their minds?

By Alice Poole

 

Accusations made by 18,000 retired American Football players over the “hiding of the damages of brain injury” has culminated in a $765 million settlement by the NFL, pending legal approval. This, combined with new research by Professor Damian Bailey of the University of Southern Wales carried out on 280 retired rugby players, has increased public attention and media focus on the long-term effects of head injuries, particularly in rugby. With the imminent start of the 15th 6 Nations competition and the forthcoming Rugby World Cup, the IRB is under increasing pressure to introduce mitigating procedures to ensure player wellbeing. But what can be done to increase player safety whilst maintaining the essence of the game?

Concussion is the hyper-rotation of the brain within the skull, following an impact or collision. Symptoms include headaches, dizziness, sleep disruption and memory impairment; only 10-15% of concussions involve a loss of consciousness and many concussions may not even be noticed by players.

Rugby6_SamuelSpencer

Second Impact Syndrome, where the brain experiences successive traumas before it has recovered from the first, was also defined following the death of 14 year old Benjamin Robinson in January 2011. He was subjected to a succession of heavy tackles during a school match, collapsing 1 minute before full-time, and was pronounced dead at hospital.

Professor Bailey has found that repetitive head traumas, especially at a young age, “can have a negative impact on the way the brain regulates blood flow”. Cerebral blood flow is vital in the maintenance of brain health, and its disruption can “accelerate brain ageing and increase susceptibility to early onset dementia.”

Concussion was the most common injury in English Premiership rugby in the 2012-13 season – 54 concussions were reported on match days, with a further five in training. The England Rugby Union recently published figures suggesting a 70% increase in reported concussions over the last 4 years, a frightening statistic considering only one in nine head injuries are supposedly reported.

Since the conversion to professionalism in 1995 rugby players have become fitter, stronger, bigger and nutritionally healthier than ever before. In his BBC documentary “Rugby’s Hidden Headache”, Tim Rogers notes that “members of the current England team are, on average, an inch taller and a stone heavier than their Grand Slam winning predecessors of 1992”. Wales’ current winger, George North, is currently 5.5 stone heavier and 7 inches taller than Gerald Davies, the Welsh winger in the 1970s.

The rule changes (lifting at the lineout, scrum engagement and the tackle area) have also lead to a more physical sport. Tacklers used to aim for the ball carrier’s legs, now they are actively encouraged to “body tackle” with the aim of forcing the opponent backwards away from the gain line. In his book “Beware of the Dog”, Brian Moore explained how the relaxing of the straight put in law has resulted in the scrumhalf feeding the ball further into their side of the scrum, making the hooking role redundant. In recognition of this, Moore notes the ERB’s active recruitment of bigger, stronger “non-specialist” hookers to try and force the opposition off the ball leading to the escalation in the strength of ‘hits’. Such changes resonate from an international level through to grassroots. In many cases, these impacts can be similar in force to those experienced during car crashes. Average pack weights are now regularly in excess of 900kg and the force going through the necks of the front rows at a scrum-time is roughly a tonne.

With the upcoming Six Nations and 2015 Rugby World Cup, interest in the sport has grown significantly. It is generally accepted that a change of attitude towards head injuries is required. Players are unlikely to self-report concussion either due to the deemed ‘admission of weakness’ or because during the game, with adrenaline pumping, they simply do not notice it. IRB has made positive progress with the inclusion of new concussion laws, stating that any player receiving a blow to the head is required to leave the field of play immediately to be examined, and any player who has been knocked out or seemingly concussed is required to exit the field for the remainder of the game. The WRU’s Six R’s (Recognise, Remove, Refer, Rest, Recover, Return) could be further supported by the Immediate Post-Concussion Assessment and Cognitive Testing (ImPACT), a computerised system that can be used by non-medical staff to accurately diagnose mild and more complex concussions.

However, some argue that these measures are not stringent enough in reducing the frequency of the initial injury. The implementation of New Zealand’s weight groupings at junior level, irrespective of age, would be beneficial considering that “younger players are more susceptible to a concussion, (and take) longer to recover.” Brian Moore is a strong advocate for the more rigorous enforcement of scrummaging laws, believing that if applied correctly, they appropriately mitigate the dangers of the scrum.

Despite this, rugby, and sport in general should be strongly encouraged for all. Professor Bailey stresses that “if you engage in physical activity three times per week across the adult lifespan, by sixty years of age the brain is functioning as if it were ten or fifteen years younger”. It is a wonderful way to keep fit, socialise and look back on terrific highs (and the odd low!) – just remember there are six R’s and not just Reading ‘Riting and ‘Rithmatic!

Photograph: Samuel Spencer