Hatfield Executive Committee fails to oust ‘Senior Man’
Members of Hatfield’s JCR Executive Committee have failed to oust their Senior Man in a vote of no confidence.
The vote took place on 24 May amid a “heated” Emergency General Meeting (EGM) in the JCR.
A majority of the Hatfield Executive Committee originally voted to hold an Emergency General Meeting to propose a vote of no confidence in the Senior Man, Maria Neary.
Neary, who has been a member of the Executive for a full year and was elected to the position of Senior Man with 65% of the vote, was accused of lying to College officers, her Executive team and the JCR, contravening eight separate articles of the JCR Standing Orders, lacking foresight and of naivety.
The Senior Man had attempted to change the title of her position from its current name to ‘JCR President’. However, she was asked why she had not included this in her manifesto, to which she replied that she had only thought of the motion recently. Other executive members, however, pointed out she had brought up the case last year and accused her of lying.
On one occasion, according to the Motion of no Confidence, “the Senior Man claimed to be unable to attend College Council due to an afternoon exam clashing with College Council at 16:15.
“At 13.30 on the day of College Council a photo was posted on her Instagram of her having a pub lunch. At 15.30, another photo was posted on her Instagram of her at Palace Green.
“After consulting the Senior Man’s exam timetable it turned out that her exam finished at 11:30am. She had no due cause to miss College Council.”
She is accused of making another Executive member attend the meeting, “requiring them to read a 108 page document in advance, despite the fact that said Exec member had an exam the next day and was not a member of College Council, and therefore was unable to effectively represent the views of the JCR.”
The Executive Committee believed: “She selected a fellow Executive Officer to second the motion, which does not appear to support the claim that it was a personal motion.”
According to the minutes from the EGM, this was a “serious breach” of duty.
One member of the JCR has said she has been accused of “doing it for personal gain”.
“As her first action as Senior Man, the timing of the motion does not suggest an effective prioritisation of actions in the best interests of the JCR.”
The motion stated: “We cannot be certain that she is promoting the view of the JCR, rather than her own personal agenda. This leads to concerns of trust when she is the sole representative of Hatfield’s JCR on a University level as required by the Standing Orders.”
Neary emailed Hatfield undergraduates on 17 May stating: “I am committed to ensuring that the JCR is transparent, honest and a place where open discussion can take place and people’s views are listened to…I am committed to endeavouring that something like this does not happen again.”
The college has also recently “adopted a stronger stance on responsible drinking policy within College, to be promoted by the College, the Executive Committee and College Bar Staff” which the Senior Man had explicitly supported.
At the bar after a formal on the 2 May, the Senior Man took part in a drinking game where “any member who failed at the game downed/attempted to down their drink whilst being chanted at by those playing the game.”
The motion concluded: “Members of the JCR perceived this to be in contravention of her obligations under the standing orders”
On the 9 May, “the Senior Man drank excessively in the College bar to the extent that she fell from her Chair to the floor. She then either refused or was incapable of getting off the floor when told to by members of bar staff. She was then lifted to her feet by those with her and taken from the bar.” This “drew many negative comments and tarnished the reputation of the position of Senior Man”.
(The EGM minutes suggest that there were two reports that she was helped up, two reports did not mention it and one said she was not helped up)
The authors of the motion “have concerns over her ability to strategically lead the JCR”.
Therefore, they concluded, “the Executive Committee is bringing this motion to the attention of the JCR [to] propose a vote of no confidence in Maria Neary as Senior Man of Hatfield College JCR”.
However, Neary received substantial support from JCR members at the EGM and a JCR member said “the Executive Committee’s integrity has been tarnished”.
According to the minutes, members made the following points:
- “Missing a meeting is [a] human error and does not warrant a vote of no confidence”
- “The Senior Man has a stressful life so can make mistakes”
- “The Senior Man had sought advice in submitting her report to College Council titled ‘JCR President”
- “The Senior Man has integrity and a willingness to act…more so than the previous Senior Man”
- There was a “claim from the Senior Man that five members of the Executive Committee do not support the motion”
In an email to Hatfield students, the Exec said “It was extremely encouraging to have so many passionate speakers on both sides.
“All of the Exec have learnt an incredible amount from the experience. Over the course of the coming year, we will make mistakes, both individually and as a collective. However, we have taken all points on board and we are determined to apply these to ensure that our future work for the benefit of the JCR is as effective as possible.
“We are working within an extremely difficult climate. As the renovation draws nearer, University management and policy changes and extra pressure is applied to College bars by the Police, this is an incredibly important time for the JCR.
“As ever, we are grateful for the support we receive both individually and as a team and we will strive to ensure that the interest of the JCR is protected in the key decisions to come.
“On that note, we encourage the continuation of high participation levels to ensure that Hatfield’s JCR retains and strengthens its reputation as an outstanding student body.
Once again, we apologise for the disruption caused to your week and wish you the very best of luck for your remaining examinations.”
When asked for comment, the Senior Man said: “I agree with the above and don’t feel it would be appropriate for me to make any further comment at the present time.”
The motion failed.

