Has #MeToo reached its legal limits?

Bryn Evans

Varun Patra is the latest figure to become implicated in the all too well known #MeToo movement, although for a slightly different reason than most others.

The co-founder and marketing head of media company Homegrown has recently stepped down after admitting to using his phone to record the audio of a sexual encounter without the other party’s consent.

Although the consensual nature of the sex remains heavily disputed— the anonymous woman alleges that the sex involved non-consensual digital penetration, while Patra maintains that all activities that evening were consensual—both parties have disclosed that Patra secretly recorded the sexual encounter using his phone’s microphone. In a statement to Rolling Stone India, Patra admitted that the decision to record was “not ok” and that he was “extremely anxious and fearful that any sexual activity, irrespective of consent, could be used against [him],” explicitly referencing the #MeToo movement

There is legitimate public worry in the face of a decisive #MeToo movement

It would be simple to brush off Patra’s decision as that of yet another insensitive media mogul. And, to

clarify, I believe he did make an irrefutably poor decision; as a non-consensual action during sex, the recording could be construed as sexual assault. Having said that, I would like to delve beyond the external facts and into the story’s meaning by asking whether Patra’s choice could represent a manifestation of very legitimate public worry in the face of a decisive and unyielding #MeToo movement.

The Indian criminal system, like practically all democratic systems, places the legal burden of proof on the prosecution. The would-be defendant Patra felt the need to preemptively gather evidence corroborating his own innocence, should the situation have come to legal proceedings. Patra’s unease was not entirely misguided.

The #MeToo movement began with a New York Times article in October of 2017 detailing allegations of sexual harassment against Harvey Weinstein. Public accusations against Weinstein now number over 80, including five ongoing criminal charges and numerous civil claims. A police recording of Weinstein admitting to groping an accuser as well as non-disclosure agreements and large monetary settlements between Weinstein and several of his accusers have also surfaced. Given the undeniable breadth of evidence, employment termination and public denunciation were delivered deservedly.

It seems irresponsible of us to pass judgement on public figures or engage in social media wars when there is little to no material evidence

The plight of others, however, has not been so morally straight- forward. US Senator Al Franken was urged by members of the public and two dozen Democratic senators to step down from office before the Senate Ethics Committee had completed its investigation into the sexual assault allegations against him.

That same month, Democratic Congressional candidate Andrea Ramsey was accused of sexual harassment by a former employee and, though she fervently refuted the accusation, was forced to end her election campaign because of the Democratic Party’s no-tolerance policy on sexual harassment. Aziz Ansari, known for his stand-up comedy and TV show, Master of None, was publicly indicted on social media after an anonymous woman contended that their date—which involved her refusal of vaginal intercourse, followed by oral sex, watching an episode of Seinfeld, and a final awkward kiss—amounted to sexual assault.

I am not alone when I say that the #MeToo movement has been a monumental and long-overdue victory for equality, both between men and women and between subordinates and their superiors.

I am not suggesting that Franken, Ramsey, Ansari, or any of the numerous other figures who have suffered losses as a result of mere allegations did not commit sexual crimes. It is undeniable, however, as Patra perhaps internalized, that the guilt of the latter accused individuals was largely presumed before any definitive evidence was gathered or due process effected.

Prejudice and inequality are exactly what #MeToo sought to eradicate

In our pursuit of justice, it seems irresponsible of us to pass judgement on public figures or engage in social media wars when there is little to no material evidence—be that legal documents, court rulings, or other—on the guilt of the accused.

Prejudice and inequality are exactly what #MeToo sought to eradicate; sexual assault is notoriously controversial given its inherent person versus person dynamic and, despite a history marred by under-criminalization, it is imperative that we now recall the judicial nature of our conversation and consider each situation objectively.

No one, in the eyes of the law, should or will be favoured: not superiors, not subordinates, not defendants, not plaintiffs, not women, and not men.

Picture by Prentsa Aldundia via Flickr Creative Commons

Image by Jacob WhiteheadÂ