Has COVID coverage eclipsed the media’s ability to hold power to account?
By Benjamin Summer
Did you know that theatres have been refused an individual extension to the furlough scheme, despite being one of the only sectors still facing government-mandated closure? You likely didn’t. As with so many news stories recently, this was dwarfed by the more headline-friendly government announcements. Throughout the pandemic, a trend has emerged where – even more than usual – the Government gets to decide which news filters through to the average reader, and which has to be hunted for throughout Twitter threads of quietly released Civil Service reports.
A cynic would say, for instance, that the government deliberately used the crisis to usher through controversial peerages, including Tory donors, a former Prime Minister’s husband, and Jo Johnson (the PM’s brother-turned-backstabbing second-referendumer-turned-best-mate-again).
The cynic would also suggest that the chatter around the introduction of compulsory masks and local lockdowns ensured the Government were under little pressure to take action following Tory MP Charlie Elphicke’s conviction for sexual assault and another Tory MP’s arrest on similar charges.
The cynic would suggest that the Government’s enthusiastic messaging around the weekly Clap for Carers dwarfed its recent refusal to include healthcare workers in announced pay rises. No prizes for guessing who this “cynic” is.
Throughout the pandemic, a trend has emerged where – even more than usual – the Government gets to decide which news filters through to the average reader.
Of course, it’s nothing new for governments to bundle controversial news in with the day’s bigger stories – it happened pretty much every week when Brexit dominated the headlines. However, we’ve seen this tactic increase in its use and its effectiveness during the COVID crisis, and this is due to two aspects of the current circumstances.
The first factor eroding government accountability is that conversations about COVID permeate literally everything else. In the early days of lockdown, endless hashtags to do with the virus topped the “trending” charts on social media – #Lockdown, #UKLockdown, #Coronavirus, #Covid19 – and when people realised the same topic couldn’t trend two days in a row, they got creative, with misspellings “Corvid2019” and “Coranovirus.” It was relentless. Other stuff simply doesn’t make the news, save for the outcry at George Floyd’s murder, rightly given the attention that such a tragedy demanded. When one story is so omnipresent, it makes it harder for anything else to even breach the surface – this in itself has meant the government is mainly held to account on only one issue.
The second factor is that, more than usual, the government’s actions directly filter through to headlines without being put through the wringer. The entire country was glued to the first few official press conferences, and we all remember Johnson’s “Nando’s hotness scale” COVID monitoring system. Rarely have BBC News’ mobile notifications been so relentless and, due to the nature of these press conferences, those notifications quote government statements almost verbatim. This has been paired slickly with Rishi Sunak’s admitted media chemistry, and memorable phrases like “Eat Out to Help Out,” “Clap For Carers,” as well as the less catchy “Stay Alert, Watch Out, Covid Might Be Hiding Behind Those Bins” range. Early in lockdown, when the Government position was touted as a direct result of “following the science,” it became almost an afterthought to significantly call the Government into question. Indeed, for a while you’d practically be accused of treason for it.
The end result of this has led to the Government’s official messaging getting an easy ride, and its other actions slipping far under the radar.
This isn’t to say that journalists weren’t readily questioning the actions of those in Government – the obvious example then is the Cummings press conference in which the Geography Supply Teacher-in-Chief turned up in the garden of Number 10 to be asked, over and over and over, whether there was in fact one rule for those in power and – wait for it – one for everybody else? No, he confirmed, there wasn’t. Oh well, nice try, we’ll get him next time. The overuse of that line and absence of any forensic questioning of why or how a trip to Barnard Castle would test his eyesight was yet another example of how the public discussion of COVID-19 has become so centred around soundbites and catchphrases that much of the meaning is lost.
Gradually, as the government’s early goodwill has begun to wear thin (helped in no small part by Mr Cummings), its hegemony over press coverage has decreased – and a whole separate discussion could be had about whether Keir Starmer has demonstrated his legal expertise with incisive questioning or dithered and allowed the government to continue unopposed. But for the majority of this daunting new era, government accountability has been hampered by blind faith in a symbolically and hollowly patriotic Prime Minister, fear of the unknown leading to excessive trust and gratitude towards those at the helm, and the charisma of an almost annoyingly attractive Chancellor. The end result of this has led to the Government’s official messaging getting an easy ride, and its other actions slipping far under the radar.
Image: Nick Fewings via Unsplash
