Guys and Dolls review: “energetic, uplifting and great fun”

By India Greenland 

Guys and Dolls was an ambitious musical to put on, being such a well loved and famous Broadway Hit. TCMS absolutely did justice to this brilliant show, filling the three hours with 1950s nostalgia, comedy and lots of fun. It was impossible not to leave in a good mood or without a smile on your face, cringingly humming the toe tapping tunes.

Director Celia Brown chose to stay true to the musical that always goes down so well in its traditional form- a decision that paid off. While not creatively risky, there were enough out of the ordinary moments to show off her excellent vision.

Choreographer Millie Blair had done an outstanding job, creating brilliant dance numbers that were slick and professional from start to finish. They were imaginative and surprising at times, while still remaining in touch with the aesthetic of the show. Particularly successful were the dynamic and energetic numbers ‘Luck be a Lady’ and ‘Sit Down You’re Rocking the Boat’ which had clearly been well rehearsed and saw huge numbers of the cast dancing perfectly in time to ambitious routines. The Hot Box Girls danced well, and there was always a vibrant atmosphere when they were on stage, aided by their excellent costumes.  

The music was all performed well. The singing was good, but the band was a triumph from start to finish. Polly Beaumont as Sarah Brown was a standout singer, especially in ‘I’ll know’ and her duet of ‘Marry the Man Today’ with Lydia Blundell as Adelaide, which I’d never found particularly special before. Who knew one would leave this show with two new feminist icons in these two characters after this perfectly choreographed and well sung, girl power number? Ben Cartwright as Sky Masterson was another vocal success in ‘Luck be a Lady’, and his sweet supporting of Sarah in ‘If I were a bell’ was a touching moment of the piece. Polly Beaumont’s handled the character of drunk Sarah very well in this scene; she was mellowed and relaxed but not too radically different from the girl who runs the mission.

 It would be impossible to highlight every impressive individual as the whole cast was of an immensely high standard. However, a standout performance was from Lottie Dick as the relatively small part of missionary and grandmother Arvide Abernalty who was a comic highlight with her excellent timing but also gave a strong and moving vocal performance in her solo. Danny Booth as Nicely- Nicely Johnson probably seemed to be the most talented actor in the show, perhaps even slightly overshadowing others on stage with him. His singing, stage presence and acting was second to none.

The script is full of good one liners and very funny moments and the director made sure that there were no missed comic opportunities. James Cummings as Nathan Detroit was good in all areas, but he carried the humour most successfully (such as in the phone conversation on stage which got probably the most laughs of the play), and Adelaide’s famous lament about her cold was great; she portrayed the complaining, eccentric character excellently and in a way that never got tiresome or annoying- no small feat when she has to pretend a quarter of her time on stage fake sneezing.

The set was a little underwhelming, but its simplicity by no means detracted from the atmosphere on the stage. The lighting looked slick and professional, but probably could have been used more imaginatively and effectively to enhance the otherwise excellent visuals. Sometimes the characters could not be heard over the band when their pieces started which was frustrating but only lasted a couple of seconds usually.

The big numbers were so impressive and so much fun for the audience that sometimes the dialogue seemed to drag a bit because you were waiting for the next song. However, the frequency of jokes stopped the audience getting bored in the longer episodes of dialogue. The play was longer than it was meant to be by an hour which I think people were very conscious of in the second half, and which wasn’t helped by the far too long interval. Despite the longer than promised running time, I was still sad when it was over.  

Ultimately, this show is a triumph: it showcases great talent and is energetic, uplifting and great fun.

Photograph: TCMS prod team