Gove’s ‘radical exam reform’ is a flawed proposal
by Alice Thickett
Having reached university, my GCSE exams seem like the distant past, so I was surprised to find myself shouting at the television as Michael Gove, Education Secretary, announced his plans for ‘radical exam reform’.
Gove is replacing the current GCSE qualifications with an English Baccalaureate Certificate or ‘E-Bac’ in core subjects, with the current year sevens being the first to take the new exams in 2017. There will be no more coursework or modules; instead pupils will sit a single 3 hour exam to determine their grades.
Admittedly, there are some sensible proposals within the list of changes: only one exam board will be allowed to provide a course for each subject, which should place students on a more level platform from which to embark on further education courses.
Yet Gove, to my mind, is deeply mistaken in placing his faith in ‘radical’ change, as for every educational reform there is inevitably a year group caught in the changeover, which suffers unfairly.
I was among the first pupils to sit the exam for the revised AQA English AS-level syllabus in 2009 and my school was shocked by a huge discrepancy between predicted and achieved grades, requiring most of my classmates to resit in the following session. Teachers simply weren’t familiar enough with the altered course to be able to teach it effectively and this endemic underachievement noticeably affected both staff and student confidence the following year.
My concern is that the much greater change that Gove has announced will result in much greater confusion or uncertainty among teaching staff, and the 16 year olds of 2017 will be disadvantaged by sitting a new course, regardless of whether or not the E-Bac is ultimately the ‘rigorous exam’ for which Gove hopes.
Furthermore, overhauling the exam system in fact renders qualifications less useful to employers and universities. Whereas the difference between a C and a D grade GCSE ought to be clear (though this has been called into question by the recent English grading debacle), the difference between an E-Bac and a GCSE will be almost impossible to gauge.
Therefore the current year sevens’ grades will not be comparable with those of the preceding year, or of their Welsh peers, who will not be studying the new course. This will also make it difficult to assess changes in standards of literacy, as will capping the percentage of examinees who can achieve the top grade, making all grades relative only to that year group.
I am not claiming that the current GCSE system is perfect. But I do object to Gove’s implicit devaluing of the qualifications I achieved. Pupils can only do as well as the system allows them to and the outgoing system has its merits.
Coursework, so distasteful to Gove, tests different skills to those which are displayed under exam conditions and is arguably better preparation for future employment. Gove does not appear to have identified the faults of the current system, rather he is attempting to change the entire qualification in one go, in order to look decisive and hard-hitting.
This is not the attitude which educational reform needs. Sudden change could be detrimental, particularly to the first year to sit the new exam, the unfortunate guinea-pigs whose grades will be affected by any teething troubles that the E-Bac is likely to experience.
The new qualification is likely to favour a much smaller group of students, rewarding those who can demonstrate exceptional memory skills in the artificial conditions of an exam hall. Tougher assessment does not equate to higher standards unless we can first improve classroom discipline and teaching, which are much greater challenges that this reform does not address.

