Gove’s exam shake up should not be judged too quickly
An exam system shake up has long been on the horizon, and after years of criticising the current system, Education Secretary Michael Gove has confirmed details of his reformed A-levels, with a similar plan for GCSEs expected to follow. By 2015, students will be sitting non-modular two-year A-levels, leaving the AS course as an isolated certificate.
As a student, an initial response might be a groan; no longer will disappointing results be remedied by an automatic resit, and there will be more pressure to perform in one final exam. No doubt this reform aims to, and in all probability will, make qualifications harder to pass. Fewer top marks will be awarded. Grade inflation will and must slow down. But a groan is certainly not my response. Gove is trying to give the children in this country a more in depth, more reputable and essentially more exciting education – something that I for one celebrate.
To appreciate the urgent necessity for Gove’s plans, we need to consider their wider objectives. It is not the content of the qualification that Gove explicitly attacks, but its structure, and the teaching culture that this encourages. A module-based, assessment-driven qualification has led to teachers focusing too much on jumping through hoops and fulfilling bureaucratic mark-scheme criteria and not enough on a genuine love of learning, on learning for learning’s sake.
In Gove’s own words, there exists ‘too much assessment, too little learning’. Underlying this attitude is a fixation on results that has superseded all other values. Teachers must get good statistics (such as 95% A*-C) which might look impressive on paper but cannot really prove that we have better educated students. The constant barrage of grades being churned out and recycled through resits assists this paranoia that impedes real learning. If both student and teacher were able to spend less time agonising over grades and more time over a two-year course marching through the avenues of say, ancient history, then the grades would look after themselves.
Perhaps a more pragmatic attitude is forgiveable when it comes to GCSEs. As the basic starting blocks we may excuse them for having a somewhat prescriptive nature. After all, rigid structure is something that many find helpful if not essential to efficient study. When it comes to A-levels, however, teachers spoon-feeding students information in order to pass modules is not to be welcomed. This kind of practise could not be further from the kind of teaching received at Universities; independent study is certainly something that ought to be encouraged more at A-level.
Although critics focus on the predicted impact of Gove’s plans on students, for me it is the teachers who will be under most pressure to perform. A student may remember what they have been spoon-fed to pass an end-of-term module exam but will they remember and demonstrate accumulated knowledge over a two-year course? This is a rather cynical view of teachers but I acknowledge that there are, of course, many inspiring, top-quality teachers and they are the people who should welcome most readily Gove’s liberating plans.
Going back to Gove’s wider objectives, he has always expressed the desire to bridge the Georgia-May-Jagger’s-front-teeth of a gap between state and private education. When discussing the flaws in our current system I speak from the experience I had at my own ‘outstanding’ state school. Things like independent study, passionate teachers and extra-curricular learning, that are largely absent in state schools, may have allowed private schools to avoid the drawbacks of a flawed examination system.
Nevertheless, Gove’s reforms are not popular. Having voted on an online poll, I found myself in the minority 13% who feel that students will be better off with two-year A-levels. Some critics fail to acknowledge that there is any foundation at all for Gove’s concerns.
Others, however, have voiced pragmatic concerns over how the new system will affect university application procedure. Lacking the important signifier of the AS grade could introduce challenges to university admissions. It is not so much Gove’s intention which will come under most scrutiny in the years to come, as his method.

