Government’s condemnable concession to coal
By George Pickthorn
In early January, the Government decided not to interfere with the construction of a new coal mine in Whitehaven, Cumbria, despite its promises of carbon neutrality by 2050. The Climate Change Committee has criticised this decision, citing the UK’s leadership of the COP 26 environmental summit this November. Speaking to Professor Simon Hogg of the Durham University Engineering Department recently about growth in the renewable energy industry, it seems to me that this decision reflects poorly on the UK’s transition to a zero-carbon economy.
Amid increasing international and public pressure, the Government has called for a ‘Green Industrial Revolution’ as part of the recovery from the COVID-19 crisis. The decision to allow the construction of the mine is clearly a step back from this agenda. Those in favour of the project, argue that the mine will produce coking coal for the production of steel which will reduce imports of this commodity. Furthermore, according to the BBC, 500 jobs will be created over a ten year period. These supposed benefits do not take heed of the climate emergency. The mine will contribute to global warming while the vast majority of the energy industry around it moves towards renewables.
The effects of climate change extend beyond standard economic cycles. In order for the UK energy sector to grow and strengthen its own skilled sustainable workforce, innovation must be at the forefront. The Whitehaven mine will produce harmful emissions and be left behind in the transition to sustainable energy. We need only cross to the North East Coast, where so much is happening offshore to bring about this change.
The Government is holding onto coal as an option when it should be dropped
In the global transition to sustainability, the UK has become a leader in wind energy. Day to day we derive around a fifth of our electricity from it. In a few years, the largest offshore wind farm in the world, Dogger Bank, will be completed off the coast of East Yorkshire. This project alone involves a vast deployment of technology and skilled workers. Dogger Bank is a member of a cluster of institutions and companies called Energi Coast. This group contains multiple institutions working to develop the offshore wind industry in the area. Research within the cluster is supported by, among others, Durham University and indeed led by Professor Hogg. Energi Coast represents an effort to expand renewable energy supply, and develop a green industry with new technologies and sustainable jobs.
Another member is Catapult, a leading centre for offshore wind technology research. An example of its ongoing work concerns the application of drones to perform inspections on turbines and blades miles from the coast. Thanks to this technology, the time needed to carry out such inspections will be dramatically decreased.
The development of Energi Coast has been supported by the Government’s new Energy white paper which was first announced in 2018. The document lays out a framework for the transition to a green recovery and while not perfect, it is a good plan to instil greater confidence in the sector. Relating to Energi Coast, the white paper aims to quadruple offshore wind energy capacity by 2030. However, the ambition of the document is undercut by the Whitehaven coal mine decision. The Government is holding onto coal as an option when it should be dropped.
The North East, once a centre of coal mining, is at the forefront of the development of sustainable energy today
The company Net Zero Teeside offers further sustainable innovation in the North East. It works to decarbonize industry in the area through the use of Carbon Capture Usage and Storage (CCUS) technology which removes carbon emissions from the industrial output. Further south in Sheffield, a company called ITM Power, referenced in the white paper, is developing hydrogen as a sustainable energy solution. One of hydrogen’s prospective uses is in steel production as a substitute for coke, the very product which the Whitehaven mine plans to produce.
The North East, once a centre of coal mining, is at the forefront of the development of sustainable energy today. The Government should be guided by a mission to prepare the nation for change as the dangers of global warming intensify. Beyond ambitious promises, decision making at the highest level must be progressive and considered, not counterproductive.
Image: Ralf Vetterle from Pixabay

