Government left in limbo as court blocks North Sea oil projects
By Irem Gozlukaya
In a landmark decision, the Court of Session in Edinburgh has revoked the UK government’s approval of Shell’s Jackdaw gas field and Equinor’s Rosebank oil field in the North Sea. The court ruled that the original consents were unlawful due to inadequate environmental impact assessments, specifically the failure to consider downstream emissions – the carbon output resulting from the eventual combustion of the extracted fossil fuels. The Court of Session in Edinburgh found that the original environmental impact assessments failed to consider the full extent of emissions from the projects, particularly those produced when the extracted fossil fuels are burned. This omission meant that the necessary climate impact calculations were incomplete, forcing the government to reassess its decision.
The ruling follows a UK Supreme Court judgment last year, which established that all fossil fuel projects must account for their total emissions, including those generated once the fuel is used. This has created a new legal standard that could have implications for future North Sea developments. The decision affects not just Shell and Equinor but also the government’s broader strategy for domestic energy production, which has been caught between the need to ensure energy security and the commitment to meeting net zero targets.
Despite the legal setback, Shell is pressing ahead with the installation of the Jackdaw gas platform, currently under construction in Norway. The platform is expected to be transported to the North Sea in the coming months. Shell has already invested more than £800 million into the project since its approval in 2022 and argues that Jackdaw will provide gas for over a million homes. The company’s CEO, Wael Sawan, has confirmed that Shell intends to appeal the ruling, emphasising that projects like Jackdaw remain critical to the UK’s energy supply.
Equinor’s Rosebank project, the largest undeveloped oilfield in UK waters, is facing similar obstacles. The Norwegian company had planned to extract up to 300 million barrels of oil, with initial production scheduled for 2026. The government’s endorsement of the project was already controversial, with environmental groups arguing that it contradicted the UK’s climate commitments. Now, following the court’s decision, Equinor must secure new governmental approvals before extraction can begin.
Greenpeace and other environmental organisations have argued that approving new fossil fuel projects while aiming for net zero emissions is contradictory
The Labour government, led by Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, has said it will move quickly to reassess the approvals. Ministers now face a politically charged decision: whether to reapprove the projects under stricter environmental conditions or to block them entirely, risking backlash from the industry and energy consumers. During last year’s general election campaign, Mr Starmer pledged not to issue any new oil and gas licences, though he stopped short of committing to revoking existing ones. The Government’s response to the ruling will be closely watched by both industry leaders and climate activists.
Environmental campaigners have welcomed the court’s ruling as a significant victory. Tessa Khan, executive director of the group Uplift, said that the decision “puts beyond doubt that new oil and gas projects must account for their climate damage.” Greenpeace and other environmental organisations have argued that approving new fossil fuel projects while aiming for net zero emissions is contradictory. They have called on the government to instead accelerate the transition to renewable energy sources.
Industry figures, however, warn that blocking North Sea developments could increase the UK’s reliance on imported oil and gas, which often have a larger carbon footprint due to transportation emissions. Proponents of domestic fossil fuel production argue that it supports thousands of jobs and reduces exposure to volatile global energy markets. Offshore Energies UK, the trade body representing the sector, has urged the government to provide regulatory certainty, warning that delays could deter future investment.
The political consequences of the ruling are significant. Sir Keir Starmer’s government must now navigate pressure from environmental groups while managing concerns over energy security and economic stability. The UK has committed to phasing out fossil fuels, but a sudden shift away from North Sea oil and gas could impact domestic supply before renewables are fully capable of meeting demand.
Image: Gary Bembridge/ Wikimedia Commons

