Government Failure to Axe Unpaid Internships

By Estia Ryan

The UK Parliament decided to block legislation aimed at banning unpaid internships. The proposed bill was debated in the Chamber two weeks ago, and aimed to secure the national minimum wage for interns. The exploitation of young people in internships is notorious in the Palace of Westminster itself, with over 20 MPs offering unpaid internships.
The proposal was put forward by Conservative MP Alan Shelbrooke, who believed that unpaid labour has become the ‘acceptable face’ of Britain today. He highlighted during the four-hour long debate that only the ‘privileged few’ can get a ‘leg-up’ and afford unpaid internships in the capital. The Sutton Trust estimated that an unpaid intern in London has expenses of around £926 a month – not a price many young people can afford.

Shelbrooke notes that unpaid internships ‘should have no place in a meritocratic country that aims to work for the many and not the privileged few’. He had hoped that this bill would encourage working-class young people to secure these opportunities.

Business minister Margot James told the Commons that the draft legislation ‘could have unintended consequences that might even undermine existing employment laws and protections’. However, unpaid interns often perform the same tasks as part-time or full-time staff. Other MPs noted that the added financial pressure on firms to pay interns would result in fewer internships. These would be more competitive and favor the elite anyway.

A similar proposal had been put forward two years ago by Labour MP Alan Milburn. He chaired the Commission for Social Mobility and Child Poverty, which showed in 2014 that top professions including the media, the law, and politics, are refusing to pay interns. He called for firms to ‘diversify their workforces’. Yet two years on, no change can be seen.

The House opted last week for more internships that will be accessible only to a privileged London elite, instead of having fewer internships accessible to all. This rigged system won’t do much to diversify an already elitist Parliament. Young people from working class backgrounds will have to look elsewhere in hopes of climbing their career ladder.

 

Image by KOC University via flickr