Google Shares Suspended In Shock Email Release
by Alex Bond
Google saw $24 billion wiped from its value last week after the world’s biggest search engine’s third quarterly results were accidently leaked three hours early.
If the leak was not enough, the figures filed with America’s Securities & Exchange Commission within the document were particularly disappointing with profits falling by one-fifth which came to the surprise of many of Wall Street. Its revenues were $11.3bn, but analysts expectation $11.8bn. Profits declined to $2.18bn, down a fifth on the $2.73bn it made in the third quarter last year.
There was further embarrassment as the release contained the line ‘PENDING LARRY QUOTE’, referring to Google’s Chief Executive Larry Page. Mr. Page was quoted as saying ‘I’m sorry for the scramble earlier today. As our printers have said, they hit send on the release just a bit early’.
Indeed, the blame for the crisis was squared at printing firm R.R Donnelley who accidently leaked the Google report ahead of schedule. Rumours were circulating that the company who is paid by Google to release its financial could face legal action.
Market reaction was almost unanimous in its opinion of the incident. When speaking to Reuters, Joe Saluzzi, co-manager of trading at Themis Trading, said: “You can’t make those mistakes anymore… it’s obvious this was some sort of mistake that went out too early. [But] mistake or not the earnings are earnings, [and] the problem is when this happens in the middle of the day, there is no time for analysts’ questions and for an evaluation”.
Sameet Sinha of B Riley stated “The core business seems to have slowed down pretty significantly, which is shocking. I don’t think anybody saw this.” She also noted that these results could indicate the decline in popularity of Google as a search engine: “The big fear has always been – what if people decide just to go straight to Amazon and do their searches? And potentially that’s what could be happening.”
Some commentators have even pointed how the figures themselves illustrate the challenges facing technology firms. Both Facebook and Apple saw shares fall by 0.5% and 2.8% respectively. It reignites a perpetual debate within the sector about technology firms generating their revenues from advertising and the challenges facing these companies to smart phones for internet usage. This sentiment was echoed by Paul Nolte, a managing director at investment firm Dearborn Partners: “It’s a huge impact on the market, and especially the tech stocks. What happened to Google is a continuation in the tech sector of some very poor earnings numbers”.
Although Clark Fredricksen, vice-president of eMarketer, which tracks the online advertising business, took a more positive view indicating that Google’s worries should not ignore its underlying strength. eMarketer shows that Google remains dominant in search, with a 74.5% share of the US search ad market and its market share in Europe is greater than 95%.
It is a rarity for events of this kind to ever occur as quarterly results are governed by strict internal procedures and require the utmost secrecy. The leak has deprived Google of the opportunity to manage market expectations and to provide an explanation and context to these disappointing figures. However, it is clear that there are greater challenges facing Google and the technology sector as a whole.
Photography: Getty Images
