Ghostwriting: the ethics of hidden authorship

By Emily Palmer

The general consensus amongst readers is the expectation that the words we read come from the “mouth” of who we believe to author them. Imagine then, an arrangement whereby someone is selected to anonymously articulate the narrative of another, would this not be literary thievery?

Ghostwriting is commonly discussed within the publishing industry, namely in relation to the ethics of essentially paying someone else to do another’s work. The unethical nature of ghostwriting is shaped by the view that it is a form of ‘cheating’ when writing, with the assumption that skilled authors are taken advantage of for their talent. Ghostwriting, when used with a lack of transparency, is frowned upon, resultant of the risk of the representing author absorbing the narrative of the ghostwriter, in effect claiming credit for another’s work and deceiving the audience through misrepresenting its source.

“The unethical nature of ghostwriting is shaped by the view that it is a form of ‘cheating’ when writing, with the assumption that skilled authors are taken advantage of for their talent”

My immediate opinion is that when used to the sole advantage of the representing author, ghostwriting seems to be lazy. It can threaten the credibility of the words in forming a division between what is written, and who actually wrote it, devising the sense of a stolen narrative. Readers may feel cheated in buying the book, expecting to read stories spoken specifically by the author they’re buying, yet finding then that the words actually belong to someone entirely different. This case relates in particular to many celebrity memoirs, many of which written by ghostwriters, disputing the authenticity of the link between the celeb and the narrative. My question on this matter then is where do we draw the line between ghostwriters and biographical authors?

The credibility of writing can be eroded by the discredited involvement of a ghostwriter, of which many would view as highly unethical. That being said, there have likely been many cases where the representing author feels they have a valuable narrative to convey, however lack the talent and skill required to do so, where ghostwriting can instead be used as a tool of articulation. In such cases, I would argue that ghostwriting is ethical, but dependent on the transparency of its use so as not to misrepresent the source of the narrative.

There are alternative perspectives of ghostwriting that stand which shed a more positive light on this controversial arrangement. Certain infamous stories would have been unlikely to come about without it, namely the Jason Bourne series written by Robert Ludlum. Ludlum only wrote the initial trilogy, unfortunately passing away in 2001, upon which the series was continued by various authors that published under Ludlum’s name. Ghostwriting can be a way to continue the legacy of an author once they are unable to do so themselves, presenting a more ethical outlook in consideration of its use. 

Popular opinions of ghostwriting certainly depend on the specific arrangement of its use, and the level of transparency that is adopted alongside. Unethical ghostwriting can be characterised by deception, where the representing author claims the ghostwriter’s words as their own, eroding the credibility of the narrative. Ethical ghostwriting involves either the balanced collaboration of both parties, or the transparent continuation of the writing of an author who is unable to do so themselves. The ethics of ghostwriting therefore lie in the connection of the words to their rightful author, and the authenticity of the narrative that is created in the honesty of its use.

Image: Ohio Humanities