Getting hammered: acceptable behaviour or the last nail in the coffin?
By Joe Gellman
Whilst universities may primarily be institutes of learning and academia, they are also a great place for thousands of young people to socialise through various different means. One of, if not the, most popular forms of socialising involve alcohol; an incredibly high number of students in the UK, myself included, enjoy drinking on a fairly regular basis. It is understandable why; when we drink, we feel calmer, less anxious, and socialising becomes a much easier task. However, on many occasions, things get taken perhaps too far and we get blackout drunk, waking up the next day with little to no memory of what happened the night before.
Identity is severed when we get blackout drunk
Most people regret such a situation having occurred for perhaps obvious reasons; the anxiety of not knowing what you said or did the night before can be overwhelming. I believe that these anxieties can be better understood through the field of philosophy and this article will demonstrate how. In order to do so, I will first define what I believe to be the most accurate theory of personal identity, before showing how this identity is severed when we get blackout drunk. Despite this, we still remain responsible for the acts of someone who we do not personally identify as. This is quite a scary issue to face up to and provides us with ample reason to not get blackout drunk, which will be the conclusion of this article.
In philosophy, the debate regarding what defines personal identity is one of the most significant in the field of metaphysics. My words on it on this occasion will be somewhat brief in this article as entire dissertations can and have been written on the topic (in my undergraduate dissertation for example, I have devoted an entire 3000-word section to the debate). Essentially, I subscribe to the view that personal identity is defined by psychological continuity. According to this view, I am who I was in the past if I am psychologically continuous with that person. If I were to suffer a traumatic brain injury and lose psychological relation to who I once was, then I would no longer be the same person. On the other hand, if my brain were implanted into another body and my psychology continued as it previously had, I would still be the same person. The rest of this article rests on the assumption that this account is an accurate one (there are both detailed theoretical and empirical arguments in favour of the psychological account of personal identity which I would invite the reader to further pursue).
I will now present two separate cases in which one has their psychological continuity temporarily severed. In the first case, Andy is living his life as usual before suddenly becoming possessed by Charlie; unbeknownst to Andy, Charlie has developed a drug that allows him to possess anyone if they consume the drug and dropped it into Andy’s coffee when he was looking away. As soon as Andy is possessed by Charlie, his psychological continuity is severed, and he cannot be considered the person he was before. It is only when the effect of the drug wears off that we can consider Andy as having returned to the person he was before.
The answer lies in responsibility and choice
In the second case, Charlie is not successful in his drug production and Andy avoids possession. That evening, Andy decides to have a few drinks. A few drinks turn into ten and he gets blackout drunk. In terms of his psychological continuity, it becomes gradually thinner as Andy gets more and more drunk until it becomes completely severed once Andy reaches the stage of being blackout drunk. At this point, we once again cannot consider Andy as the same person as he was before, and it is not until the next morning when we can consider Andy as having returned as the person he previously was.
We thus have two separate cases where Andy temporarily does not exist as the person he identifies as under normal circumstances. Now let us imagine two similar events occur in each scenario. In the first scenario, Charlie’s maliciousness does not end with mere possession. It turns out that he has a great hatred for Andy’s friend John and makes Andy murder John whilst he is under his control. In the second scenario, whilst blackout drunk, Andy enters a drunken rage and murders John.
In both scenarios, Andy is arrested and taken to court to answer for his crime. In the first case, Andy pleas that he was under Charlie’s possession and that the person who killed John was not him. After providing irrefutable evidence of the drug Charlie used, showing it was used on him, the court finds Andy innocent and sends Charlie to prison for the crime instead. In the second case, Andy pleas that he was under the influence of incredibly high levels of alcohol and that the person who killed John was not him. The court rejects Andy’s pleas and sends him to prison.
Responsible, both in the court of law and the court of public opinion
Intuitively, we would tend to agree that the outcomes in both scenarios are fair. But surely there’s a contradiction here? In both scenarios, the person who murdered John is not Andy as he usually identifies, yet in only one of these cases is Andy held responsible for the crime that occurred. The answer lies in both responsibility and choice. Firstly, when a crime is committed someone must usually be held responsible. In the first case, it is clear that Charlie is responsible and is thus sent to prison. In the second case, there is no external individual who can be blamed, and Andy is therefore found guilty. However, this does not seem to go far enough. If Andy had killed John whilst sleepwalking, would he have been sent to prison? The answer is probably no; cases of people killing someone whilst asleep do exist and they tend to be found not guilty of murder. We then must ask what the difference is.
For me, the difference is choice. Andy chose to get drunk in the second scenario. He did not need to get blackout drunk, but he did; he therefore must face the consequences of the crimes he committed whilst drunk, even if they were not committed by someone he identifies with. If we did not hold people accountable this way, one could simply use getting blackout drunk as an excuse to commit any sort of crime, which would have repugnant outcomes for wider society. Essentially, Andy’s imprisonment would act as a warning for others about the consequences of overconsumption of alcohol.
We are thus left in a position where when blackout drunk you are responsible, both in the court of the law and the court of public opinion, for the actions of an individual who you are not psychologically continuous with and thus do not share personal identity. This situation is quite scary and can be used to explain why we feel such anxiety when we wake up with little memory after a night of heavy drinking. Hopefully this provides an ample philosophical explanation of our attitudes around getting blackout drunk, and thus shows why it is something that should be avoided.
Image: Thom Masat via Unsplash

