Germany is allowing its past to colour its behaviour in the Eurozone

by Al Russell

In Greece, the German government is seen as the villain in the country’s economic pantomime. Angela Merkel has been portrayed in the Hellenic press in Nazi uniform, seen to be dictatorial in imposing, through the European Union, conditions of austerity on Greece. However, the deal agreed in the last week to give Greece another loan package in return for the more of the cost-cutting measures that have so riled the country’s public, seems in reality to have been pushed through by the Gallic duo at the centre of the attempts to revitalize the Eurozone – Nicolas Sarkozy and his former finance minister, Christine Lagarde.

There is a very vociferous faction of the Greek public that is firmly set against the course of austerity that the IMF plans require. In a country that until recently rewarded civil servants with a punctuality bonus, this is not surprising. However, is Germany really a fair target for Greek ire? Although public opinion in Greece is against Germany, in the belief that the latter has imposed not only austerity, but an unelected government on the former, Germany is guilty of a very different crime: failing to command the situation to the extent that a country of its prominence should. German hesitancy to push through another rescue package for Greece comes from a deep rooted self-fear in German politics.

Ever since the Second World War there has been a propensity in Germany to shy away from the international limelight, born out of a deep shame of what happened the last time Europe found itself under Teutonic dominance. Post-reunification German politics has been a celebration of government by weakness. A federal system overseen by broad coalitions in national government means that dominance has been very hard to achieve and accountability has been paramount; German action on the international stage has been uncontroversial and low key. This post-war desire to be an also-ran on the world stage is central to the German hesitancy to throw its weight around within the Eurozone. So is anti-German sentiment in Greece unmerited?

British Shadow Chancellor Ed Balls doesn’t think so. In a recent BBC interview, before the latest IMF package was agreed, he compared Greece to a patient bleeding to death, highlighting that hesitation from those with the power to save it could only be damaging. Similarly, Radek Sikorski, the Polish Foreign Secretary (and Bullingdon Club contemporary of Boris Johnson) said in a recent speech that he was probably the first Polish statesman ever to call for stronger German action in Europe, but that he did so keenly. A hesitant Germany cripples the European Central Bank, which is unwilling to act without the explicit backing of its largest shareholder, thus putting the Eurozone, and by extension the wider European economy, in even greater danger.

Germany must accept its power and take the lead on the European stage. Its government must not be scared of forceful action, which can surely do no more damage to its reputation than its current policy of stuttering over important issues. Germany is already getting the blame in Greece for EU/IMF actions, so it should ensure that it plays a role in shaping them. For the German people this may be a difficult pill to swallow, but they must have faith in their government and in the European system, and must realise that decisive German action is crucial to turning round the ailing European economy.

What’s your view on the Eurozone crisis? Join the debate below or tweet us @PalatiComment

Photograph by Matthew Kinloch