George Osborne: should a politician rule our newspapers?

By Samuel Betley

Recently, it was announced that the new Editor of the London Evening Standard, the freesheet familiar to any regular traveller on the Tube, would be none other than MP George Osborne. That’s right. The commuters of our great capital will soon be exposed to the arbitrary editorial decisions of a man whose greatest achievement in journalism is being shortlisted for The Times trainee scheme in 1993. He was swiftly rejected. How did this happen? And what does this mean for both politics and journalism?

On a basic level, there is absolutely no problem with a senior politician, or a politically-minded public figure, holding a top position at an influential newspaper. In fact, there is an indelible link between the political and journalistic spheres. Figures such as Boris Johnson and Michael Gove arrived in the House of Commons after cutting their teeth as journalists. Piers Morgan, the former editor of the Daily Mirror, now fills his Twitter feed with political invective. Before every general election and even last year’s referendum, national newspapers exhort the nation to vote in a particular way. This is how a free press works. In 2015, various major newspapers endorsed the Conservatives, Labour, a continued Tory-Liberal Democrat coalition, and even UKIP. We should be proud of this diversity. There are no reasonable objections to a newspaper being edited by someone with a clear, well-known political bias.

However, the new editor of the London Evening Standard is no ordinary Conservative. George Osborne ran the Treasury for six years on behalf of David Cameron. This has led his supporters to argue that he is used to doing two jobs at once – Chancellor of the Exchequer and constituency MP. These people forget that since his sacking by Theresa May, Mr Osborne has hardly been twiddling his thumbs. George Osborne has not one, but six jobs. He remains on the backbenches, while also chairing the Northern Powerhouse Partnership, making speeches for an extortionate fee (he obtained £800,000 in the last year from this alone), and earning a cool £640,000 on the side by advising the asset management firm BlackRock. As a sitting MP, Mr Osborne earns roughly 10% of what he does as a glorified financial adviser. When his new role at the London Evening Standard is added to this, it amounts to nothing less than a betrayal of the constituents of Tatton that he was elected to serve.

The positive aspects of his appointment that can be drawn from a journalistic perspective are overwhelmed by his responsibilities as an elected representative. He simply cannot do his main job to the required standard any longer. In this context, is it likely he ever wanted to make a difference to his constituency in the first place? George Osborne’s sights have always been set on greater things.

Surely Mr Osborne must see some benefit from taking up the editorship of the London Evening Standard? We are dealing with a man who is used to surveying the political landscape from the very top of greasy pole. Over the last nine months, the establishment seems to be losing control of the political landscape in the West. In the United Kingdom, the Labour Party appears to continue to provide no meaningful opposition to Theresa May’s government. No political vacuum goes unfilled for long. Reports have been circulating for months that George Osborne has been in contact with figures including Tony Blair and Nick Clegg in relation to forming a new centrist party; something speculated by Tim Shipman, in his recent book ‘All Out War’. At any rate, talks have ensued between Tony Blair and Osborne amongst others, regarding setting up a centre-ground political institute. If this happens, a friendly newspaper in London would be a very useful ally. Whether or not the establishment can be revived by an inexperienced and deeply unpopular newspaper editor, however, still remains to be seen.

Nevertheless, the relationship between journalism and politics will remain a deep and interdependent one. Yet not so deep that one man can edit a major newspaper and pretend to represent his constituency in Parliament, alongside four other jobs. George Osborne must choose.

Photograph by altogetherfool via Flickr and Creative Commons