Gender will never be a clear-cut issue
by Justin Villamil
It would appear that Sweden has handed me a Christmas gift a few weeks early.
The Top-Toy Group (a Toys “R” Us licensee and Swedish toymaking giant) has responded to pressure from the Reklamombudsmannen, Sweden’s advertising watchdog, and released their new holiday catalogue and it’s gender-blind.
Yes, you read that right. It’s gender-blind. Girls playing with toy guns! Boys playing with dolls! Madness. Anarchy. And fundamentally a brilliant step towards gender equality in today’s society.
No, I’m not a new-age hippie. I recognize the problems with allowing children to choose their own genders and I also understand that one firm’s decision is probably not going to stop parents from buying blue for boys and pink for girls.
I’m also American, which means I tend to look at Sweden (with its full complement of functioning political system, economy, and ice fishing) with a mixture of distrust, envy and puzzlement. But for once I have no problem looking past all this.
Sweden is a country with about nine million people, which is just slightly over the population of London.
So – according to the Wall Street Journal – the government of Sweden has every incentive to put gender equality at the forefront of everything in order to maintain output. If women start dropping out of the workforce then the consequences could be dire. This fact allows the country to justify intervention in the market and simultaneously be at the cutting edge of gender rights.
But back to the main issue. Why do I think Sweden is right in doing this? Because frankly, when I walk into a shop to do some holiday shopping I don’t want to see the boy’s section (Transformers and army men) on one side and the girls section (Barbie and dress-up sets) on the other. Blue and pink. Manly and frilly.
When we limit ourselves to these choices aren’t we always clamping down on experiences these kids could have had? And aren’t those experiences necessary?
For young children in a modern world facing a growing need to be interesting, we should be encouraging cross-gender experiences. This is how women learn to break from a stereotype and men just generally learn to… stop being cavemen (you know I’m right).
Unfortunately, our capitalist society has a way of taking trends and, seeing profit, solidifying them. Companies see that there is money to be made by breaking consumers in half and marketing to them separately depending on gender and excluding tastes.
It’s not their fault, it just is. But here’s the point: it doesn’t have to be. Somewhere along the line, someone has to break the cycle. In this case, it might just be the people of Sweden and, by extension, a government agency.
But is there a line? Could we be on the proverbial slippery slope to our genderless demise? Thomas Pascoe of the Daily Telegraph thinks so, characterizing Sweden’s attempts at gender-neutrality as “treating women as men” and claiming that “no boy grows up dreaming of being a princess”.
There is a point to be made here. Last year Sweden deliberated the usage of a genderless pronoun. Hairdressers aren’t allowed to vary their prices depending on gender. Could we conceivably go too far in our advocacy? Has Sweden?
No. I feel confident contending that gender equality measures designed to maximize freedom are fundamentally things to pursue. Practically, intervention in the market may need to be scaled back as we balance social needs with economic ones (especially for hairdressers).
However, from a social standpoint I fear I cannot share the moral outrage that some critics seem to have adopted. “Some men just don’t look good in dresses” is about as far as I can go towards looking down on boys wanting to be princesses.
So as our Christmas season merrily opens its arms to recieve fat wads of currency, perhaps consumers could demand a higher standard than the classic 50/50 approach.
In response to demand earlier this year, Harrods opened a store with toy placement based around interests rather than gender. If we can take Harrods, we can take the world.

