Gaza’s Stability Equation: Do Electricity Shortages Correlate to Regional Stability?

By Pia Comer

Disclaimer: this article was written prior to Israel reigniting military action, launching extensive strikes in Gaza on 18th March due to Hamas’ refusal to return Israeli hostages.

Gaza, a narrow strip of land, yet also one of the most densely populated territories worldwide, is blighted by a humanitarian crisis, engendering ever direr implications not just for its 2.1 million inhabitants but also for regional stability in the surrounding Middle East. Israel
cutting electricity supplies to Gaza on 9 March represents more than just a punitive policy: an increasing hazard of reigniting violence, increasing the possibility of demolishing an already tenuous ceasefire supposedly. But does this humanitarian deterioration necessarily threaten the ceasefire? The evidence presents a more nuanced reality.

In Dr. Sara Roy’s words, “electricity is not merely a convenience but a prerequisite for modern society”; conflict resolution research indicates that asymmetric adversity fosters optimal conditions for hostility – an exemplification of the correlation between human jealousy and violence. Access to basic services is related to reductions in militant conflict as humanity resorts to extremity in times of crisis. The International Crisis Group found that the modern ceasefires which failed most rapidly were characterized by “severe deterioration of
civilian infrastructure during supposed periods of calm”. Ceasing electricity may thus counteract the maintenance of peace – the very aim that Israel espouses.

However, what is oft-unrecognised in this debate is the existence of alternative supply chains: given that all 10 power lines from Israel to Gaza were cut off on the very first day of aggression (October 7, 2023), power crises are not a novel concern in Gaza. Even before the
current crisis the territory operated on what constitutes life support: Gaza received merely 120 megawatts from Israel, a minute amount in comparison to their minimum demand of 400 megawatts – electricity in Gaza has never been abundant. Residents have grown accustomed
to harsh rationing schedules: roughly four hours of power followed by twelve hours without.

Residents have grown accustomed to harsh rationing schedules: roughly four hours of power followed by twelve hours without.

Prior crises have necessitated adaptation: over half of Gaza’s electricity is now detached from Israeli control, and 86% of Gaza’s hospitals have backup energy generation methods. This hardly minimises Gaza’s humanitarian crisis but does mean that basic life is capable of being
sustained in manners which might not manifest elsewhere. Israeli cessation of electricity to Gaza has thus had little impact beyond desalination plants which, admittedly, has considerably exacerbated Gaza’s water crisis as no functioning desalination plants remain in
Gaza.

In what Hamas has referred to as “unacceptable blackmail”, Israel’s electricity policy aims to motivate Hamas to extend the existing ceasefire and return the remaining hostages. Israel’s coercive strategy coupled with Hamas’ refusal to compromise despite civilian destruction
embodies the most tragic outcome of game theory: a non-cooperative equilibrium. Such situations often result in mutually destructive wars of attrition whereby both sides endure mounting costs while waiting for the other to capitulate. The Gazan game is so perilous because the “chips” being wagered take the form of human lives.

Breaking this destructive equilibrium requires a “coordinating mechanism”, a third-party mediator with sufficient credibility to structure simultaneous concessions, allowing both parties to move toward cooperation without appearing to have acceded to one another. Perhaps most importantly, both the formal and informal diplomatic channels that typically maintain ceasefires in the Middle East operate independently of local power grid status, flowing through third-party mediators in Egypt and Qatar, both of which are unaffected by
local power disruptions.

Ceasefires only end when one or more parties calculate that military action serves their strategic interests – a decision matrix that incorporates more variables than mere civilian infrastructure. Paradoxically, when survival becomes the primary struggle in warfare, the
incentives for maintaining peace do not necessarily diminish proportionally. Potentially, using electricity as a bargaining tool is one which will trigger solutions.

Humanitarian crises often trigger increased international engagement, strengthening rather than weakening ceasefire mechanisms. The panic engendered by humanitarian crisis intensifies international mediation efforts accordingly. Humanitarian concerns thus frequently
serve as a catalyst for renewed diplomatic initiatives rather than a trigger for renewed hostilities.

As Gaza descends further into darkness, the question remains whether the light of diplomacy will illuminate a path forward before the perilous peace is extinguished entirely.

Resting on a bedrock of long-standing hostility, the current ceasefire in the Middle East is definitively fragile. Whilst conventional academia may suggest that cutting electricity supplies will inevitably undermine peace efforts, there is room for a more nuanced reality.

Historically, ceasefires have both collapsed following humanitarian deterioration – think Syria’s Aleppo province in 2016 – and yet have also demonstrated remarkable resilience despite infrastructure challenges, exemplified by the Lebanon-Israel border in 2006.

Infrastructure and diplomacy exist in constant conversation with each other, neither wholly independent nor completely intertwined. The complex web of diplomatic channels, alternative supply mechanisms, and strategic calculations that currently sustain peace operate with a degree of independence from civilian infrastructure status.

Peace in the Middle East seems to have survived through greater hardship, and ultimately only time will tell as to whether electricity cessation will prove to be a catalyst for renewed conflict, a hyperbolised media fiction designed to attract our ever-shortening attention spans, or, like most things, somewhere in between two extremes: a mere addition to longstanding issues between two historically hostile countries. As always, stability in the Middle East remains elusive.

Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons/ Jaber Jehad Badwan