Gary Lineker and an epitaph to impartiality

By Jerry Li

The BBC is in some trouble. There were calls for the Chairman’s resignation amidst waves of public discontent over the suspension of Gary Lineker. The furore was sparked by Lineker’s rather polemical comments about the government’s immigration policy, comparing government rhetoric to 1930s Germany.

In an overt political statement, the former England international football player is accused of breaking the BBC’s social media guidelines. Many, like the Free Speech Union, say that the suspension was a curtailment of Mr Lineker’s freedom of expression, amounting to ‘cancel culture’ at the core of British public life. The backlash was football pundits’ solidarity boycott of BBC’s flagship Match of the Day programme, as well as intense exchanges within the House of Commons.

This incident is a dire indictment of the polarisation of national discourse. Whilst the BBC eventually caved into pressure and reinstated Lineker with no discernible consequences, the statement is sure to be irksome to 53% of Britain, who, according to a recent YouGov poll, agrees with the government stance on illegal immigration. The BBC has striven to hold the impartial centre ground in Britain for all of its existence, yet embattled by both sides in politics, such a line is increasingly impossible to tread. The Left has accused the corporation of unfairly treating Jeremy Corbyn and having an impact in his defeat in 2019, while the Right has alleged that the BBC fails to represent popular attitudes outside a London bubble, especially with regards to Brexit, and has been entertaining policies such as the privatisation of Channel 4 and scrapping of license fee.

The BBC is supposed to be a sign of national consensus, television that every Briton could watch and identify with

In this instance, to suspend Lineker over criticism of Conservative rhetoric’s seems to confirm the suspicions of the Left. That the BBC is in the pocket of the government: indeed, the ‘Yes, Minister’ trope of “of course the BBC cannot give into government pressure” springs to mind. On the other hand, allowing its highest-paid presenter – known to be firmly anti-Brexit – to publicly compare a Conservative Government to the Nazis hardens the Right-wing conviction that the BBC is hostile to their opinions. Regardless of whether it retains the substance, the brand of impartiality has lost its credit.

The BBC is supposed to be a sign of national consensus, television that every Briton could watch and identify with. Indeed, the invaluable World Service still presents values to the world most Britons could stand for. Yet domestically, the limit of impartiality is apparent in such a divided political landscape. The BBC emerged at a time when Britain had a rather more united vision of herself and has ever since been seen as the gold standard of media and broadcasting.

In a country which holds freedom of expression as a core tenet, so long as one steers clear of legally proscribed speech, that liberty ought to reign supreme

Yet such unity is no more. Many pearls are to be clutched over the prevalence of social media, which has transformed public discourse. Despite the bitter class divide in the 70s, the BBC’s position is now more precarious than ever. ‘Culture war’ that raged on with particular vehemence in the wake of Brexit consumes public opinion. Behind Lineker’s statement is an entrenched mutual distrust within public discourse which makes impartiality and the sort of freedom of expression he would like struggle to coexist. Indeed, a simile to the Nazis could be justifiably seen by some as incendiary, even if they also disliked HM Government’s policy.

In a country which holds freedom of expression as a core tenet, so long as one steers clear of legally proscribed speech, that liberty ought to reign supreme. There would be no case to silence him, however many frowns his comment might have raised, had he been employed elsewhere. However, for one as prominent in the BBC as Lineker, it is inconceivable for that his tweets could be seen purely in a private capacity. The BBC remains interpreter of its own guidelines, yet Lineker’s reckless exploration of its limits brought the full force of public attention to bear on the lifelike body of its brand of impartiality.

Image: Dunk via Flickr