Fusion’s promise and the path forward

By Jared Toudic

Fusion’s Promise

The world is on an unsustainable path. Humans emit around 51 billion tons of greenhouse gas, of which carbon dioxide is the main culprit. This carbon dioxide (and other greenhouse gases) increases the heat trapped in the atmosphere. Analysts have assigned an unaccounted cost of this emission to around $185 per ton, indicating that trillions of dollars of unaccounted cost are now manifesting and will further manifest as a plight of intense heatwaves, droughts, crop failures and destruction of the natural world. What is particularly concerning is that we greatly risk perturbing the planet into a highly unstable state – further heating will lead to melting ice caps, allowing for additional absorption of heat as the white ice no longer reflects the heat and a potentially devastating large-scale release of methane from melting permafrost and undersea methane hydrates. In this scenario, we would observe a non-linear progression of the climate crisis, one that accelerates ever faster, with us being left to observe the horror which unfolds.

The most challenging part of this situation is how we tackle this problem. Decarbonisation is extremely difficult: in 2020, the International Energy Agency forecasted the share of fossil fuels in total energy use, declining from 80% of global demand to just 72% by 2040. Of the 20% currently electric, around 60% is produced by fossil fuels. The general mood for transition is sluggish, with US oil production and world coal consumption both at an all-time high.

Fusion, the energy process of stars, has the promise to deliver. It could provide a consistent, energy-dense supply with no high-level nuclear waste or any possibility of weapons proliferation

An effective transition requires us to electrify the means of production. Degrowth is a popular argument used by activists. Still, I don’t buy it: in a hypothetical scenario where everyone lived at the poverty line in Denmark – defined at $30 a day – the global economy would have to be at least five times bigger than it is today. GDP is closely tied to energy use, and fossil fuels dominate energy use. Electrifying the means of production, such as electric cars, heat pumps, and green industry, whilst ensuring the electricity is from clean sources would simultaneously produce economic prosperity and prevent the pernicious effects of climate change.

However, this would require a colossal quantity of clean electricity. Fusion, the energy process of stars, promises to deliver. It could provide a consistent, energy-dense supply with no high-level nuclear waste or any possibility of weapons proliferation. It could do this with a fuel cycle that could last thousands of years, at least.

The Path Forward

The fusion of hydrogen isotopes, deuterium and tritium, is currently the most promising. Deuterium can be obtained from heavy water, which occurs naturally in seawater, while tritium can, in theory, be produced from lithium, already mined on a large scale for batteries. The reaction is:

The reaction produces a helium nucleus and a neutron, releasing 17.6 MeV of energy as heat. In comparison, the strongest chemical bond has an energy of about 11 eV, meaning that a fusion reaction emits one million times more energy! The concept is that strong magnets will confine a plasma composed of deuterium and tritium. The two most promising methods for achieving this are the tokamak (left), which features a simple doughnut shape, and the stellarator (right).

Image: US Department of Energy / Large Norwegian Encyclopedia

Image: Max-Planck Institute for Plasma Physics / Large Norwegian Encyclopedia

The last few decades of fusion research have centred on creating a confined plasma that produces more energy from fusion reactions than is needed to heat and confine it. This is quantified by an equation known as the Lawson criterion, which, in simpler terms, indicates that we need a sufficient ‘triple product’ of density, temperature, and ‘energy confinement time’ (a metric describing the plasma energy loss rate). A higher value corresponds to a higher Q, the ratio of energy output to energy input. The current record for Q was set on the Joint European Torus at Culham, near Oxford, in 1997 with a value of 0.67.

One may lament that this record has not been broken in such a long time. However, things are about to change very soon. Commonwealth Fusion Systems, a spinout company from MIT, is building a tokamak called SPARC, which utilises breakthrough high-temperature superconducting magnets. These stronger magnets enable a higher Q. SPARC is projected to achieve a Q between two and 11 and is set to begin operation in early 2026. The demonstration of gain in SPARC will change how we perceive fusion –  it will no longer always be 30 years away.

SPARC is projected to achieve a Q between two and 11 and is set to begin operation in early 2026. The demonstration of gain in SPARC will change how we perceive fusion – it will no longer always be 30 years away

The path forward shall be based on how we effectively harness this technology. In particular, the tokamak may be the first machine to achieve gain; however, it may not be the best option as a power plant since it must operate on pulses. SPARC will indeed have net energy but will operate on only about ten seconds of pulses. Furthermore, the tokamak requires a current to be driven through the plasma, which can lead to events known as ‘disruptions’, where the unstable plasma slams against the chamber’s walls. A disruption could likely damage a power plant scale machine, which is highly undesirable given the substantial upfront cost expected in building it.

The stellarator may provide the solution we need. These devices operate continuously rather than in pulses and do not experience disruption events. Their triple products were initially low, but thanks to recent breakthroughs in design – utilising computational optimisation – they can be tailored for higher energy confinement times. Furthermore, abandoning the simple doughnut shape introduces around 50 degrees of freedom compared to the four for the tokamak, creating a wealth of possibilities for future designs. The validity of the optimised stellarator as a power plant is currently being investigated at the Wendelstein 7-X device in Greifswald, Germany, aiming to demonstrate fusion-relevant plasmas in continuous operation. Its success would represent a significant breakthrough toward a fusion power plant.

Image: Steve Jurvetson via Wikimedia Commons