Funny Money: The Benefits of Bulk
by Jessica Medhurst

More than once Grandma inadvertently caused an in-store stampede.  As her heavily-laden trolley, creaking like an overloaded battle-tank, trundled past, Grandma’s startled fellow shoppers would suddenly infer an impending shortage of whatever she was buying at the time, and would charge the shelves in unison in a crazed dash for the remaining items. It was bedlam.
Granted such scrupulous penny pinching may seem painstakingly boring (which, stampedes notwithstanding, it is), but this is deeply rooted in economic theory. Economies of scale do exist; be it financial economies of scale (why large banks with huge amounts of collateral are able to borrow at lower interest rates), or network economies of scale (why Facebook becomes more interesting the more people that use it) or simply productive economies of scale (lowering storage and ordering costs by bulk purchases), which is the same thing that allows my Grandmother to live so frugally.
Which is a funny thing to notice, given that when we rang up The Ritz to enquire about booking to celebrate my Grandmother’s 75th birthday (I promise this is the last mention of her), the notion of economies of scale did not seem to exist. For five people to eat would have cost £55 per head. However, a group of nine people would not be allowed to select the £55 menu, instead moving to another menu at £67 per head. So under what circumstances do economies of scale not hold?
The most obvious thought that came to mind was that perhaps, on a small scale, the most significant cost would be that of ordering inventory. For example, if crates of smoked salmon come in batches large enough to supply, say, seven people at a time, for five people to have tea would mean only one crate would have to be ordered, and two people worth of smoked salmon is wasted. Yet for nine people to have smoked salmon sandwiches, two crates would have to be ordered, so that would mean four servings of smoked salmon are wasted. Thus costs are higher, and the principle of economies of scale (just about one of the only concepts in economics where there is little dispute), disappears.
You may argue that this is nonsense; as the Ritz is a huge enterprise, surely they service such a large number of people per day that the problems of fiddling with small numbers are negligible? It would be more logical and far less wasteful, for any wasted smoked salmon from one table to be reallocated to another.
However, this is counter balanced by the fact that the ingredients the Ritz is likely to be ordering are probably very expensive, and so over ordering on ingredients for the day could mean much lower profits than they would like. Furthermore, many of the ingredients for afternoon tea are very perishable indeed, so the idea of storing ingredients to smooth out ordering cycles could be tricky.
Thus, in this circumstance, where the service that is offered is of very high quality, and has to be performed on an individual level, the notion of economies of scale loses its traction. Granny would not be happy.
Photograph: FourTildes on Wikimedia Commons
