Funny Money: Economics – A Game of Morals?
by Jessica Medhurst

It might seem crazy, and I have never been one to fawn over small children, but this analogy has been implicitly passed around in our headlines since the wake of the 2008 financial crisis. If children behave badly, parents are inclined to punish them, and if an economy is tanking, the ‘naughty step’ equivalent is austerity. Without getting too far into the metaphor, there does seem to exist an innate human instinct to exact karma, to reprimand what has gone wrong.
The rioters in Greece seem to encapsulate this perfectly; as Greek productivity is low and fiscal deficits high, they received huge doses of austerity in the form of public sector job cuts and retractions of the safety net of welfare benefits. Many uncompetitive Eurozone countries cannot devalue their currency (as they are tied to the euro), so they have to try to improve their current account deficit by internally reducing wages. This, in short, is all that is needed to kick start a recession.
But doesn’t it seem foolish to indulge more in people who have, as a government, spent too much, and as citizens, are criticised for not being productive enough? Instinctively, we might think that punishment seems more appropriate than a reward for a petulant economy. How much of this policy is being exacted due to sound economics, and how much is due to our own gut instincts?
John Maynard Keynes, whilst talking about the Great Depression of 1929, said that the economy was suffering from ‘magneto trouble’; the magneto being a miniscule part of a car that can be replaced inexpensively, used in turning on the engine. As well as characterizing the starting problems an economy can have whilst growth is stagnating and confidence is low, it also shows that the problems of a recession can be fixed far more cheaply than the damage they create: the side effects cause much greater damage than the solution.
This seems counter-intuitive; surely getting 2.53 million people in the UK out of unemployment should require a more complex solution than just providing fiscal stimulus? Yet in the 1930s it worked, injections from the New Deal and the funding of World War II gave rise to the ‘Golden Age’ of the 1950s and 60s.
The idea of tightening our belts and punishing profligacy does appeal to our inner disciplinarian. Constant fear of the ‘bond vigilantes’ should keep intervention by fiscal policy to an absolute minimum, lest suspicion of ‘the socialists in the White House’ sends interest rates soaring. This is actually logically sound: inflationary policies reduce the real value of money and thus can send interest rates in an upwards spiral. But the evidence suggests otherwise; even as the Federal Reserve and Bank of England pampered our economy with quantitative easing, and the Obama government launched $787bn worth of fiscal stimulus, by the beginning of 2012, US borrowing costs were at an all time low.
So, for depression economics at least, the petulant child is still screaming, and the debate still raging between reward and reprimand.
Main Illustration: Claire Ewbank
Photograph: Public Domain
