Funny Money: As You Like It

by Jessica Medhurst

Facebook-like-button32

A few months ago, after a pretty standard Wednesday night at Loveshack (filled with the usual round of Gangnam Style and sweaty freshers), my friend Christine and I headed out to Pizza Uno. We had toyed with the idea of Urban Oven, dabbled in Woksupp, but eventually the thirty percent student discount won us over. The drunken chatter of kebab addicts, the Turkish chefs shouting at each other in the background – all of this was music to our ears.

As we indulged in the grease, we started up a conversation with the manager, and Christine soon found herself honoured with the title of “Mrs Uno”. No doubt, from that night on, we made sure never to miss out on a visit to Pizza Uno after a Wednesday night session in Loveshack, such was the joy that came with the grand title of “Mrs Uno”.

In the same way that the manager at Pizza Uno gained our loyalty by naming Christine, other, larger chains attempt to gain the same luxury of personal affiliation. However, their very scale is a hindrance to this, for example, we would not blindly devote ourselves to Topshop just because of a friendly cashier. Is there, thus, a trade off between specialisation, economies of scale and consumer loyalty? It would seem so; Western economic institutions make impersonal trading on a large scale very possible and the gains from specialisation realisable. Private property rights and the strong upkeep of the law make market incentives inherent and undeniable.

Incredibly, amongst all of the advertising techniques and economic indicators, personal attention is still the most effective way of getting your customers to like you.

In a sense, firms can achieve a more personal relationship with the consumer just through branding (take Innocent Drinks for example; even the name suggests a virtuous corporation), or by ethical practices.  M&S consistently let it be known in their stores about their ‘Plan A – because there is no Plan B’, which is their code of conduct combatting environmental damage, social inequality and the promotion of more sustainable lifestyles in the developed world. Of course, every company taking that line has to perform the same near-impossible balancing act – to manage the inherent contradiction between saving the environment (less consumption) and buying their products (more consumption).

By the same token, to build up allegiances between the firm and the consumer, large supermarket chains (in oligopolistic competition like Pizza Uno) draw on loyalty schemes, such as Nectar cards at Sainsbury’s, or Clubcards at Tesco. Firms can even take this a step further; infiltrate social networking sites and advertise there by providing pages to ‘like’, or statements to retweet. Mars have recently started a campaign where you purchase a special code from a vending machine, tweet it with the given hashtag about Mars, and then receive a special prize. No doubt this is to attract customers by the allure of a surprise gift, raise revenue and build up consumer loyalty and familiarity with the brand, given that the word ‘Mars’ will now appear countless times on Twitter. Of course, this can sometimes backfire and produce a negative reaction from consumers if they feel that there is no media space free of advertising.

So apart from the thirty percent student discount, Pizza Uno has to find a way to fend off competition from Woksupp and Urban Oven. Its handy geographical location (right opposite Loveshack) is both a gift and a curse, as it also means that it is next to a cluster of similar restaurants. Lowering prices will only take them so far.  Even though students are likely to be very sensitive to price, it is very hard to compare prices across a whole menu quickly and easily. Incredibly, amongst all of the advertising techniques and economic indicators, personal attention is still the most effective way of getting your customers to like you.  Naturally, one would never find Mrs Uno straying to Urban Oven.

Photograph: Public Domain