From Durham’s modern marvel to an eleventh century Castle

Alison Moulds

Josephine Butler Formal

“You don’t know where the formal is, do you?” I ask my taxi driver, as the cab crawls its way up to Josephine Butler college, in order for me to start yet another (pretty bizarre) social experiment.

This time last year I tasked myself with dating representatives from each and every college, and now I’ve been advised to replicate the experiment once more. But this time instead of rating boys, I’m attempting to rate each college’s formal experience, everything from dining to dress code.

Within five minutes I’ve worked out that this is going to be even more terrifying than dating strangers, and not only due to my penchant for constantly getting lost. Naming and shaming individual men is one thing but taking on college formals constitutes a whole new danger zone. Last year I received covert death threats on the Studio dance floor, now I’m fully prepared for all-out poison pen letters.
So, back to my cab. My richly-rewarded driver offers me some actually-impeccable instructions, and I soon manage to locate the bar, and find it rather embarrassingly empty.

I take the plunge and find a stool and yes, now  I am clearly embracing my loneliness, sitting by myself in the intimidatingly huge bar, doing my best impression of an actually-really-popular-person, clearly just nonchalantly waiting for a whole horde of my bessies to turn up.

Which only gets more embarrassing (and  apparently) less convincing the moment actual groups of friends begin to file into the bar. Since clearly my act isn’t quite as polished as I presume, within moments my Indigo Ed’s friend approaches me, having been warned by her pal I might be on my lonesome.

We’re quickly joined by my host for the eve, the then-Social Sec Natalie who despite donning daunting chav-style gear as part of the theme is eager to put me at ease.  Yes, themes. Butler is all about the themes, and I’ve managed to score an invite for its bravest, boldest innovation yet. This is the topsy-turvy formal, where everything is quite literally backwards- not only in terms of dress code (interpret as you wish, I’m surrounded by everything from clowns to people in pyjamas), but the whole formal ritual is played back to front, including dessert being served up as a starter.

Natalie assures me she’s done her best to find the least stomach-turning combination of dishes, and as such the sweet melon and poached pear dessert-cum-starter, works well followed by a pesto and cherry tomato tatin (or braised beef for the carnivores), with a cheese and ‘bacon’ conclusion.

Besides a flutter of fear regarding something masquerading as meat nestled amongst my salad, I should say that the food was generally TOP NOTCH, which probably comes from the usually self-catered Butler having to hire outside caterers to furnish them with food for formal occasions.

For some reason university formals seem constantly concerned with depriving people the chance to actually pass urine, as if bodily functions need to be ruthlessly suppressed in polite society. Am I the only person who thinks actually preventing people from using a toilet is a lil’ bit more of a social faux pas? Yes people this is a formal dinner, not a sweatshop.  Thankfully, Butler appeared to be one of those rare few where you can actually USE THE TOILET.

As such, one can slowly ease into the post-formal entertainment without dashing out to queue for the loo as soon as high table is dismissed. And finally Butler’s bar, which seems to swamp drinkers on a standard evening, is put to good use. Whilst it definitely recalls my days of school discos in the gym, this one is (thankfully) devoid of any lingering body odour, and instead invested with decoration, music and a whole host of partygoers. This isn’t just dinner, it’s an event, and boy, do Butler do it well.

Castle Formal

My next formal invitation comes in the form of a bribe, at least that’s what I think might be happening when my Come Dine With Me co-contestant Greg promises free alcohol for me and my fellow diners at Castle. And if this is bribery, then it certainly doesn’t disappoint. Our evening begins in the wood-panelled MCR, where I’m passed a gin and tonic upon arrival, and allowed to hob-nob with a lot of dinner jacket-donning postgrads. I feel as if we’re at a weekend hunting party, and Poirot is about to walk through the door any moment and tell me which one of my fellow guests has already offed the butler on the back lawn.

My high hopes of such continued poshness are dashed however. I’m disappointed to find high table (where I’ve been given a seat) is blocked off from the rest of the Great Hall by some rather annoying scenery and scaffolding, which are being used for a current stage production. Without being able to actually see most of the diners, I feel deprived of the opportunity to feign superiority over them all (clearly the point of a high table).

On the other hand, I’ve never got to wear a dress and gown in such a suitable place. In fact I almost wish I’d ignored the standard formal attitude of plumping for something somewhere between wedding reception and Klute, and gone all out with some sort of Cinderella-style ball gown instead. In a modern college, it’s hard not to feel like you’re playing at being posh in the most incongruous of surroundings.

Thankfully the food has picked up a bit since Medieval times, although it’s not quite as ostentatious as the surroundings would have me hope for. A bit of soup and some veggie lasagne is pretty standard formal fayre, it’s by no means poor quality, but it does dent a little bit into my dream that I’m in Gosford Park. Plus, I’m a tad disappointed to find my soup swiped from under me by the waiting staff, before I’m anywhere near draining the dregs.

Following dinner we retire to the SCR, which is even more elegant than the MCR but demands the ability to navigate a lot of rickety steps in the kind of stilettos I can’t even walk in at the best of times. Add to the fact I’ve now consumed almost a bottle of wine as per formal tradition, this really isn’t the easiest of tasks. In the SCR, guests are permitted to finish off their formal bottles or help themselves to tea and coffee, the most restrained way I have ever wound down a formal.

Yet Castle seems to offer the best of both worlds, whilst I hear there’s dancing and possible debauchery in the bar, we’re approached asking if we’d like to attend a post-dinner talk on Darwin. I decline the offer but then feel I should have fought the gin haze into finding the energy to attend, just to have the sort of formal experience I’ll never have again.

Although, in general, my Castle formal was just a tad too salubrious for my liking, it was still an unrivalled chance to partake in a little elegance. I still nurse hopes of an invitation to one of the more debauched formals down on low table (cough*hint*cough), but until then I’ll keep my fond memories of gin-soaked dining in  the beautiful Great Hall.