Free speech should be without conditions, we’ll all be better people for it

By Matthew Chalmers

The modern Left, which I am prepared to heavily associate myself with, has developed a singularly annoying trait: the trait of chauvinistic infantilism. Let me clarify what I mean. Chauvinistic infantilism refers to what Person One exhibits in this sample of dialogue:

Person One: What did you vote for in the EU referendum?
Person Two: I voted for Brexit. Immigration has introduced a lot of pressures into my community and I think the levels of it are unfettered and dangerous. I just want my children to have good jobs, that’s all.
Person One: How could you say that? You’re racist!
Person Two: I’m not racist, I just told you that I’m facing real problems and…
Person One: (Screaming) RACIST!

Such behaviour is infantile. It shows zero engagement with anything that contradicts the speaker’s views. It results in labelling people with charged, emotional and unneeded terms (racist, fascist) because one’s infantile approach refuses to acknowledge deviance from the liberal, left-wing canon as anything more than crypto-BNP support. It is chauvinistic for the same reasons; any critics of one’s position are immediately exposed as undercover SS corporals who feast on the flesh of immigrant children.
Where has all the thought gone? Where’s the civility, the debate, the critical thinking?

I am of course being more than a little facetious, and I generalise my comrades far too meanly. Moreover this problem is not endemic to the political Left. But it is disappointing to see the above attitude in so many people.

I think, for one, there’s a culture, which we help grow at university, of being nannied. Of feeling entitled to be protected from nasty ideas, or even contradictory ideas. It can be quite an arrogant culture, the type that pooh-poohs UKIP as a fringe protest movement, as if it didn’t get nearly four million votes in 2015, because nobody could possibly be that stupid.

The NUS’s policy of no-platforming undesirable speakers encapsulates this culture, and indeed promotes it. The ‘free-speech for some for the safety of others’ policy they promote is patronising and intellectually insulting.

The childish desire to be protected from scary ideas, and to dismiss Nigel Farage and co. as phantasmagorical bogeymen is not entirely our fault. It is natural to seek out others who agree with you, and one can easily become immersed in a bubble of friends, especially at university, who all broadly support your politics.

However, I am bored of furiously agreeing with my brothers and sisters on the Left. I want hard debates back, ones which ignite our tempers, make us grind our teeth, scratch tables with fury, to speak with burning passion. I want to become more militant in my resolve and to do this I need to battle some disgusting ideas.

What I mean is let’s toughen up. I love and celebrate secularism, LGBT rights, women’s rights, anti-fascist movements, democracy, welfare. These are cornerstones of leftist ideology; I want these cornerstones to be crudely challenged so we can rediscover why it is we upheld those ideas in the first place.

This, in my view, will help breed a tougher, more critical and more fiercely independent generation of students, be they left or right wing. This is the kind of spirit we need out there in the world, not the sluggish, boring moan of the ‘I’m offended therefore you’re wrong’ attitude I’m growing tired of hearing. The old liberal theory that in a free market of ideas the best will emerge triumphant still holds weight.

So I say let loose the fascists, the Islamists, the homophobes. To cower behind the skirts of no-platforming is to admit that you haven’t any confidence in your belief system. To say ‘I find your beliefs so detestable that I won’t let you speak’ is ultimately a painfully weak position, and an obvious insult to free-speech. Say rather ‘I find your beliefs so detestable that I will not hold back in dismantling every filthy lie you can muster’. It’s the difference between locking the monster in the attic and bundling it into the incinerator.

No more no-platforming and no more chauvinistic infantilism. Let’s come together and engage in challenging, aggressive debates in which no stone is left unturned, no moral unquestioned. We’ll be better people for it.

Photograph by Newton Graffiti via Creative Commons