Free Schools, Free Pickings

By Jade Azimschools

They will “create more local competition and drive-up standards.” That’s what the Conservative Party had to say on the establishment of Free Schools. Is it me, or should that be their main Party slogan?

Watching 10 O’ Clock Live a while ago with the famously dry Charlie Brooker, I picked up on a segment in which he discussed more ‘choice’ in the NHS to drive competition as a part of the Health and Social Care Act. He used an analogy in which he started with a top-of-the-range “Hesten Bloomenthal Taste the Difference locally-sourced Amethocaine with morphine shavings” as the most costly option, and then contrasted it with the NHS value range version; namely, “A can of cheap lager, and a stick to bite on while that medical student saws your bum off.”

This, he believes, is what ‘choice’ – that is, what the Conservatives say is the best asset of Free Schools- produces; vast inequality. In the case of Free Schools, this means inequality within local communities.

The same episode of 10 O’ Clock Live used another segment, this time from Question Time, when Phil Hammond questioned a Tory MP on how many times the word ‘competition’ came up in the Health and Social Care Act. He hadn’t a clue, or at least pretended not to, but it turns out the word came up 86 times, compared to the word ‘cooperation’ which came up a spectacular zero times.

The words ‘competition’ and ‘choice’ are used very often, often together, and always in a positive way, by the Conservative Party and subsequently the Coalition whenever they try to sell a policy that involves some form of ‘liberalisation’ of certain institutions. The television examples I used were of the NHS, but could quite easily be substituted for the debate surrounding Free Schools. Liberalisation to create more choice and competition in this view appears spectacularly malignant, ranging from transport, to healthcare, and now to education.

But wait, what exactly ARE free schools, and how can they be lumbered with the word ‘competition’? To put it simply, Free Schools were set up in 2010 as an extension of the Academies Act. The first Free School to open was the West London Free School in Hammersmith. Toby Young, the co-founder and a not-insignificantly wealthy journalist, was successful in signing a Funding Agreement with the Secretary of State for Education. These schools are funded by taxpayers, and free to attend, but unlike the curriculum-based schools of the old are not controlled by a local authority, making it possible for parents, teachers, charities and businesses to set up their own schools.

“BUSINESSES?!” I hear you cry. Well yes, and many opponents have pointed out that Free Schools could be considered a move towards privatisation of education ‘by the back door’, much in line with…well…a lot of things recently. And there again pops up another grand opportunity to use the words ‘competition’ and ‘choice’.

Opponents of free schools have also challenged the shortcomings in freedom of information access related to the development of such schools, meaning many individuals have almost unparalleled freedom to set up a school as they wish, not governed by any particular standard –even allowing for the possibility of a person with absolutely no experience in education taking it upon themselves to the build a school from the ground up – but through the benefit of any funds they may have that could either be less than or substantially more than the budget of any state school.

No doubt there is clearly room for a huge extent of disparity in the creation of these schools, as well as in comparison to existing schools. This only serves to add to the major inequality between public and state education as it existed before Academies or Free Schools. However, now we have yet another division, this time within the taxpayer-funded system too. Here arises a new microcosm of the good old ‘haves’ and ‘have nots’ paradigm.

Indeed, critics have argued that the policy will benefit only middle-class parents –or indeed, any wealthy body that would benefit- with the time to set up free schools, and that they will divert money away from existing schools, particularly at a time when investment in state education is so low.

However, the government has consistently dismissed this, despite many considering the project to have been a waste of money with no evidential support to suggest a ‘drive-up’ of standards. The government instead insists they will help with social mobility, benefitting pupils from all walks of life. But then, this is flawed logic, is it not?

Only communities with a large amount of money will be able to set up these schools, and if a poorer community attempted to do so the inevitable product would be a school with far lesser standards than their richer counterparts.

But, of course, the government doesn’t see it this way, as it never does. But this is the real meaning behind the code-words ‘competition’ and ‘choice’.  The only thing waiting at the end of this ‘liberalising’ road is the rich having greater choice, and the poor losing out in the competition.

Image credit: scui3astevo via Flickr